What Is to Be Done? · Chapter
VIII: The Temptation of Hamlet explained
Marya Alekséyevna, feigning a headache, orchestrates a private conversation between Viéra and Lopukhóf, then eavesdrops.
What happens
Marya Alekséyevna, feigning a headache, orchestrates a private conversation between Viéra and Lopukhóf, then eavesdrops. They discuss the theory of rational egoism, with Lopukhóf arguing that all human actions are motivated by self-interest. Viéra tests the theory by asking whether she should accept a rich suitor she dislikes; Lopukhóf advises her to choose what is most advantageous. Marya Alekséyevna, overhearing, approves of the conversation as it seems to support her own plans.
Themes in this chapter
Rational Egoism
Central to the chapter: Lopukhóf argues that all human actions are driven by self-interest, and Viéra tests this theory in her personal dilemma.
Freedom and Individuality
Viéra explores the freedom to choose based on her own interests, challenging societal expectations of marriage.
Characters to notice
- Marya Alekséyevna
Eavesdrops on Viéra and Lopukhóf's conversation, approving of Lopukhóf's rational advice.
- Viéra Pavlovna
Engages in a philosophical discussion with Lopukhóf about self-interest and tests the theory by considering a rich suitor.
- Dmitri Sergéitch Lopukhóf
Explains the theory of rational egoism, arguing that all actions stem from self-interest, and advises Viéra to choose what benefits her most.
- Feódor
Delivers Marya Alekséyevna's message asking Viéra and Lopukhóf to move their conversation.
Key passages
“Theory must by necessity be cold. The mind must judge of things coldly.”
Lopukhóf asserts that rational analysis requires emotional detachment.
Highlights the rationalist approach to ethics.
“Weigh everything; choose what would be most advantageous.”
Lopukhóf advises Viéra to make decisions based on her own best interest.
Key advice reflecting the theme of rational egoism.