The Lives and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers · Chapter
Zeno, the Eleatic explained
This chapter details the life, character, and philosophical contributions of Zeno of Elea, a pupil of Parmenides known for his invention of dialectics, his political courage in opposing tyranny, and his doctrines on multiple worlds and the
What happens
This chapter details the life, character, and philosophical contributions of Zeno of Elea, a pupil of Parmenides known for his invention of dialectics, his political courage in opposing tyranny, and his doctrines on multiple worlds and the nature of matter.
Themes in this chapter
Political Engagement and Tyranny
Zeno's plot to overthrow the tyrant Nearches and his courageous death exemplify political resistance and the philosopher's engagement with tyranny.
Death and Legacy
The chapter recounts various accounts of Zeno's martyrdom and his enduring reputation as a noble philosopher and inventor of dialectics.
Natural Philosophy and Cosmology
Zeno's doctrines include the existence of several worlds, no vacuum, and the nature of all things as a mixture of hot, cold, dry, and moist elements.
Characters to notice
- Zeno of Citium
Zeno of Elea is the subject of the chapter; he is described as a native of Velia, pupil of Parmenides, inventor of dialectics, and a noble figure in philosophy and politics.
- Parmenides
Zeno was a pupil of Parmenides and greatly attached to him; Plato mentions Zeno in his Parmenides.
- Aristotle
Aristotle, in his Sophist, is cited as saying Zeno invented dialectics.
- Heraclitus
Zeno is compared to Heraclitus as a despiser of great men.
- Empedocles
Aristotle is said to have compared Zeno's invention of dialectics to Empedocles' invention of rhetoric.
Key passages
“Great is the strength, invincible the might Of Zeno, skilled to argue on both sides Of any question, th’ universal critic”
Timon praises Zeno's formidable skill in debating any topic from both perspectives.
This epigram highlights Zeno's dialectical prowess.
“Your noble wish, O Zeno, was to slay A cruel tyrant, freeing Elea From the harsh bonds of shameful slavery, But you were disappointed; for the tyrant Pounded you in a mortar. I say wrong, He only crushed your body, and not you.”
An epigram on Zeno's failed attempt to assassinate the tyrant, noting that while his body was destroyed, his spirit remained unconquered.
This reflects the theme of death and legacy.
“If when I am reproached, I am not angered, then I shall not be pleased when I am praised.”
Zeno responds to criticism by saying that indifference to blame implies indifference to praise.
This illustrates Zeno's philosophical equanimity.