Orley Farm · Chapter
Mr. Moulder Backs His Opinion explained
As the trial approaches, John Kenneby is terrified of being cross-examined.
What happens
As the trial approaches, John Kenneby is terrified of being cross-examined. Dockwrath keeps close watch on him and Bridget Bolster, while Moulder accompanies them to Alston. Over tea, Dockwrath and Moulder argue about the likely verdict, and Moulder challenges Dockwrath to back his opinion with a ten-pound bet.
Themes in this chapter
Justice and Injustice
Joseph Mason's bitter sense of having been robbed for twenty-two years and his desire for retribution contrast with the legal maneuvering and uncertainty of the trial.
Truth and Deception
The witnesses are coached and guarded, and both sides manipulate the narrative; Moulder and Dockwrath's bet underscores the gamble of truth in court.
Characters to notice
- Mr. Moulder
Accompanies Kenneby to Alston, argues with Dockwrath about the trial outcome, and offers a ten-pound bet to back his opinion.
- Samuel Dockwrath
Manages the witnesses, expresses confidence in a guilty verdict, and accepts Moulder's bet.
- Mr. Kenneby
The terrified witness who wishes to run away; he is closely watched by Dockwrath and accompanied by Moulder.
- Bridget Bolster
A solid, square woman and witness for the prosecution; she enjoys the prospect of being well fed during the trial.
- Joseph Mason of Groby
Travels first class to Alston, expresses his long-held grievance and desire for justice against Lady Mason.
Key passages
“I’ve so set my heart upon this—upon getting justice at last—that I do think it would kill me if I were to be beaten.”
Joseph Mason is so emotionally invested in winning the case that he believes losing would destroy him.
Reveals the depth of Mason's obsession with the trial.
“Give me the man that can fight a losing battle. Anybody can play whist with four by honours in his own hands.”
Moulder admires a lawyer who puts up a strong defense even when defeat seems certain, comparing it to playing a card game with a weak hand.
Highlights Moulder's respect for resilience and fair play.
“I’ll put that in John Kenneby’s hands, and do you cover it.”
Moulder offers to place a ten-pound note with Kenneby as a stake, challenging Dockwrath to match it.
Illustrates Moulder's confrontational style and his confidence in an acquittal.