Yama · Chapter
XI explained
In a brothel private cabinet, tensions rise as Boris Sobashnikov drunkenly insults Platonov, accusing him of being a pimp.
What happens
In a brothel private cabinet, tensions rise as Boris Sobashnikov drunkenly insults Platonov, accusing him of being a pimp. Jennie provokes the conflict with malicious glee, while Likhonin tries to mediate. Platonov warns Sobashnikov, who leaves with Petrovsky out of 'solidarity.' Jennie reveals her disgust after a client, and Platonov brings the exhausted Pasha to rest, having learned she was taken by many men. The chapter highlights the exploitation of the women and the hypocrisy of the male patrons.
Themes in this chapter
Hypocrisy of Society
Male patrons like Sobashnikov condemn Platonov as a pimp while themselves participating in the exploitation of the women.
Dehumanization and Commodification
Pasha is treated as a commodity, taken by multiple men in one night, and Jennie's disgust highlights the dehumanizing cycle.
Female Friendship and Solidarity
Jennie defends Pasha against the housekeeper and tries to help her rest, showing solidarity among the women.
Characters to notice
- Sergei Ivanovich Platonov
Remains calm under Sobashnikov's insults, warns him, and later brings Pasha to rest.
- Jennka
Provokes the quarrel with malicious joy, reveals her disgust after a client, and defends Pasha.
- Boris Sobashnikov
Drunkenly insults Platonov, accuses him of being a pimp, and leaves in indignation.
- Likhonin
Tries to calm the quarrel and covers Pasha with his coat.
- Tamara
Observes the conflict silently and is asked by Likhonin to give Pasha chocolate and wine.
- Pasha
Exhausted and ill after being taken by many men, brought to rest by Platonov.
Key passages
“Jennie, who had all the time been looking intently at the student, gaily and maliciously flashing with her sparkling dark eyes, suddenly began to clap her hands. “That’s the way! Bravo, little student! Bravo, bravo, bravo! … That’s the way, give it to him good! … Really, what sort of a disgrace is this! When he’ll come, now, I’ll repeat everything to him.””
Jennie watches the argument with delight, clapping and encouraging Sobashnikov to insult Platonov, threatening to tell Platonov later.
Jennie's malicious enjoyment of the conflict reveals her turbulent soul and desire for scandal.
“She poured out half a glass for herself and drank the cognac off at a draught, distending her thin nostrils wide.”
Jennie quickly drinks half a glass of cognac in one gulp, flaring her nostrils.
Shows Jennie's distress and coping mechanism after her encounter with the German client.
“Platonov got up in silence and went toward the door. “It’s not worth while, Sergei Ivanich. Drop it …” Jennie stopped him. “Oh no, why not?” objected the reporter. “I shall do a very simple and innocent thing, take Pasha here, and if need be—pay for her, even.””
Platonov rises to fetch Pasha; Jennie tries to dissuade him, but he insists on bringing her to rest, even offering to pay.
Platonov's simple act of kindness contrasts with the exploitation around him.