The Viaduct Murder · Chapter
Proof at Last explained
Reeves reveals to Gordon that he has solved the murder, identifying Marryatt as the killer.
What happens
Reeves reveals to Gordon that he has solved the murder, identifying Marryatt as the killer. He presents a chain of circumstantial evidence: Marryatt took the Momerie book from Reeves' room, gave it to Brotherhood, sent a theological cipher message, traveled on the 3:00 train to establish an alibi, behaved suspiciously after the body was found, and lied about knowing Miss Rendall-Smith. Reeves proposes a test using the walking stick to confront Marryatt.
Themes in this chapter
Deception and Secrecy
Marryatt's lies about knowing Miss Rendall-Smith and his concealment of the Momerie book highlight the theme of hidden truths.
Detection and Rationality
Reeves uses logical deduction and evidence reconstruction (e.g., the washing-list) to build his case, showcasing rational detection.
Appearance vs. Reality
Marryatt appears as a respectable clergyman but is accused of murder; his calm demeanor masks guilt.
Characters to notice
- Gordon Davenant
Reeves confides his solution to Gordon, who is skeptical but listens.
- Mordaunt Reeves
Reeves presents his detailed case against Marryatt, including the deciphering of the washing-list and the plan to test Marryatt with the stick.
- Marryatt
Accused by Reeves of murdering Brotherhood; Reeves outlines his motives, alibi, and suspicious behavior.
- Mr. Carmichael
Referenced in the discussion about the photograph of Miss Rendall-Smith and the proposed test method.
- Miss Rendall-Smith
Her photograph and identity are discussed as part of Marryatt's suspicious behavior.
- Old Brotherhood
The victim; his relationship with Marryatt and the gift of the Momerie book are key to the case.
Key passages
“Well, it clearly wasn’t part of the cipher, was it?”
The list on the back of the cipher letter is not part of the code.
Reeves and Gordon discuss the significance of the washing-list.
“I have solved it, and I wish to God I hadn’t.”
Reeves regrets his discovery of the murderer's identity.
Reeves reveals his solution to Gordon.
“It was Marryatt who took out my Shakespeare; he wanted to look up a quotation for his evening sermon.”
Marryatt entered Reeves' room under the pretense of a sermon preparation.
Reeves explains how Marryatt accessed the Momerie book.