All chapters

The Middle Five · Chapter

The Splinter, the Thorn, and the Rib explained

The boys exchange stories about creation, comparing an Omaha legend of a thorn turning into a girl with the biblical story of Adam and Eve.

What happens

The boys exchange stories about creation, comparing an Omaha legend of a thorn turning into a girl with the biblical story of Adam and Eve. Their storytelling is interrupted by Graybeard's discipline and later by the supper bell. The chapter also includes Frank's aunt removing a splinter from his toe, prompting further discussion of the thorn legend.

Themes in this chapter

  • Tradition vs. Modernity

    The boys compare an Omaha creation story with the biblical Adam and Eve narrative, highlighting the tension between indigenous traditions and Christian teachings.

  • Childhood and Play

    The boys engage in imaginative storytelling and playful debates, even as they face discipline from Graybeard.

Characters to notice

  • Me

    Narrator; participates in storytelling and has a splinter removed from his toe by his aunt.

  • Brush

    Tells the biblical story of Adam and Eve; aspires to be a preacher; defends the minister.

  • Edwin M. Stanton

    Tells the Omaha legend of the thorn turning into a girl; his loud storytelling wakes Graybeard.

  • Graybeard

    Disciplines the boys for loud talking after being woken up.

  • Lester

    Interrupts the stories with questions; laughs at Brush's imitation of the preacher.

  • Warren

    Argues about the difference between a snake and a serpent; wakes up confused after the cloud-rubbing dream.

Key passages

  • I want to know all about these things so I can be a preacher when I get big. I'm going to wear a long black coat, and a vest that buttons up to the throat, and I'm going to wear a white collar, and a pair of boots that squeaks and reaches to my knees

    Brush expresses his ambition to become a preacher, describing the formal attire he plans to wear.

    Shows Brush's aspiration and the influence of Christian missionaries on the boys.

  • That was my aunt; she saw me when she was going by, and she made me sit down and she looked at my foot. She took a great big splinter out of my toe. My! it hurt.

    The narrator explains that his aunt removed a large splinter from his toe, causing him pain.

    Connects to the chapter's title and the subsequent discussion of the thorn legend.

The Middle Five — The Splinter, the Thorn, and the Rib Explained