The Haunted Bookshop · Chapter
XIII: The Battle of Ludlow Street explained
Aubrey wakes early to follow Roger to Philadelphia, suspecting him of collusion with Weintraub.
What happens
Aubrey wakes early to follow Roger to Philadelphia, suspecting him of collusion with Weintraub. He trails Roger to Leary's bookstore in Philadelphia, where he confronts him angrily. Meanwhile, Roger had been summoned to appraise the Oldham library, but upon arrival discovers the invitation was a hoax. The chapter ends with Roger humiliated and Aubrey's suspicions unresolved.
Themes in this chapter
The Art of Bookselling as a Profession
Roger's pride in being recognized as a 'lover of books' rather than a mere tradesman highlights the distinction between commerce and genuine bibliophilia.
Mystery and Adventure
Aubrey's stealthy pursuit of Roger and the revelation of the hoax summons add layers of intrigue and suspense.
Characters to notice
- Aubrey Gilbert
Aubrey wakes at six to follow Roger, trailing him to Philadelphia and confronting him at Leary's bookstore.
- Roger Mifflin
Roger travels to Philadelphia believing he has been summoned to appraise the Oldham library, only to discover it was a hoax.
- Titania Chapman
Aubrey thinks fondly of Titania during his early morning wait, and Roger compares Philadelphia girls unfavorably to her.
- Mr. Weintraub
Aubrey expected to see Weintraub on the train, but he does not appear, deepening Aubrey's suspicions.
- Mr. Oldham
Mr. Oldham is the Philadelphia collector who is surprised by Roger's visit and clarifies that he never summoned him.
- Miss Patterson
Mr. Oldham's secretary, who confirms that no appointment was made with Roger.
Key passages
“It would be as impossible for any bibliophile to pass this famous secondhand bookstore as for a woman to go by a wedding party without trying to see the bride.”
A book lover cannot resist stopping at a renowned secondhand bookstore, just as a woman cannot help but look at a bride at a wedding.
Aubrey's observation about the magnetic pull of Leary's bookstore.
“This invitation confirms what I have always said, that the artist, in any line of work, will eventually be recognized above the mere tradesman.”
Roger believes that true artistry in any field will be valued more highly than mere commercial skill.
Roger's self-congratulatory thought about being chosen to appraise the Oldham collection.
“I'm exceedingly sorry, Mr. Mifflin. More sorry than I can tell you—I'm afraid someone has played a trick on you.”
Mr. Oldham apologizes and suggests that Roger has been the victim of a practical joke.
The moment Roger realizes the summons was a hoax.