The Great Illusion · Chapter
Part III: The Practical Outcome explained
This chapter examines the practical consequences of the 'optical illusion' of conquest, arguing that the real outcome of war and conquest is not national prosperity but economic and political interdependence.
What happens
This chapter examines the practical consequences of the 'optical illusion' of conquest, arguing that the real outcome of war and conquest is not national prosperity but economic and political interdependence. It critiques the notion that war is a necessary or beneficial instrument of policy, showing that conquest often leads to financial burdens, administrative challenges, and the eventual integration of conquered territories into a global economic system. The chapter also addresses the psychological and moral arguments for war, refuting the idea that human nature is unchanging and that war is an inevitable expression of national vitality.
Themes in this chapter
Economic Futility of War
The chapter argues that conquest does not bring economic gain but rather financial burdens and administrative costs, making war economically futile.
Interdependence of Nations
Angell emphasizes that the modern world's economic and financial systems are so intertwined that conquest disrupts the conqueror's own prosperity.
Characters to notice
- Norman Angell
Central figure; author of the work, presenting the argument that conquest is an optical illusion and that economic interdependence makes war futile.
- General Bernhardi
Cited as a proponent of the militarist view that war is a biological necessity and a means of national progress, which Angell refutes.
- Prince Bismarck
Mentioned in the context of the Franco-German War indemnity, illustrating the financial consequences of conquest.
- M. J. Novikow
Referenced for his work on the economic interdependence of nations, supporting Angell's thesis.
Key passages
“The real outcome of conquest is not the enrichment of the conqueror but the creation of a complex set of financial and administrative problems.”
Conquest does not make the conqueror richer; it creates a host of financial and administrative headaches.
Summarizes the central argument of the chapter.
“The interdependence of nations has made war an anachronism, a survival of a barbarous age.”
Because nations are so economically linked, war is now an outdated and barbaric practice.
Highlights the theme of economic interdependence.