The Crowd · Chapter
I: Remote Factors of the Opinions and Beliefs of Crowds explained
This chapter examines the remote factors that prepare crowds to adopt certain beliefs and reject others.
What happens
This chapter examines the remote factors that prepare crowds to adopt certain beliefs and reject others. These factors—race, traditions, time, institutions, and education—shape the mental soil in which immediate factors later germinate. The author argues that race is the most dominant influence, that traditions are the synthesis of a people's soul and are clung to tenaciously by crowds, that time is the great creator and destroyer of beliefs, and that institutions are effects of a nation's character rather than causes of its progress.
Themes in this chapter
Race and National Character
Race is presented as the foremost remote factor, dominating all others and shaping the genius of a people's beliefs, institutions, and arts.
Role of Traditions
Traditions are described as the synthesis of the race, guiding crowds and resisting change; they are both necessary for civilisation and obstacles to progress.
Institutions Are Effects, Not Causes
The chapter argues that institutions are products of a nation's character and cannot be arbitrarily changed; they are labels that often mask underlying continuity.
Social Change and Revolution
The French Revolution is used to illustrate how remote factors prepare the ground for sudden outbursts, and how violent revolutions often fail to truly alter traditions.
Characters to notice
- Unknown Narrator
The narrator presents the theoretical framework of remote factors influencing crowd beliefs.
- Crowds
Crowds are the subject of analysis, described as conservative and tenacious in clinging to traditions.
- M. Lavisse
Quoted regarding the slow formation of political and social organisations over centuries.
- Macaulay
Referenced as an authority on the Anglo-Saxon approach to constitutions, contrasting with Latin countries.
Key passages
“The remote factors are those which render crowds capable of adopting certain convictions and absolutely refractory to the acceptance of others.”
Remote factors make crowds open to some beliefs and completely closed to others.
Defines the core function of remote factors in shaping crowd receptivity.
“Traditions represent the ideas, the needs, and the sentiments of the past. They are the synthesis of the race, and weigh upon us with immense force.”
Traditions embody the accumulated ideas, needs, and feelings of the past, forming the essence of a race and exerting great pressure on us.
Highlights the powerful and synthesising role of traditions.
“Institutions and governments are the product of the race. They are not the creators of an epoch, but are created by it.”
Institutions and governments arise from the character of a people, not the other way around; they are shaped by their era, not shapers of it.
Summarises the chapter's argument that institutions are effects, not causes.