The Coming of Bill · Chapter
Mr. Penway on the Grill explained
Mrs.
What happens
Mrs. Porter interrogates Mr. Penway about Kirk's whereabouts, learning that Kirk has fled to Connecticut with Mamie. Meanwhile, Keggs witnesses the elopement and informs Mrs. Porter upon her return, revealing that Ruth has also left for Tuxedo due to a family crisis. Mrs. Porter then confronts Mr. Penway about his unhealthy habits, leaving him shaken.
Themes in this chapter
Individualism vs. Interference
Mrs. Porter's relentless interrogation of Mr. Penway and her plans to track Kirk highlight the tension between personal freedom and external control.
Eugenics and Heredity
Mrs. Porter's critique of Mr. Penway's physical deterioration and her earlier 'saving' of George Pennicut reflect her eugenicist beliefs in improving human stock through discipline.
Characters to notice
- Mrs. Lora Delane Porter
Interrogates Mr. Penway, learns of Kirk's escape to Connecticut, and later lectures Mr. Penway on his health.
- Mr. Penway
Lies to protect Kirk but is easily broken by Mrs. Porter's interrogation; later reflects on his own health after her criticism.
- Kirk Winfield
Flees to Connecticut with Mamie; his actions are the subject of the chapter's investigation.
- Mamie
Elopes with Kirk, packing a suitcase and leaving with him in an automobile.
- Keggs
Witnesses Kirk and Mamie's departure and later informs Mrs. Porter, relishing the drama.
- Ruth Bannister
Has left for Tuxedo to visit Mrs. Bailey Bannister after a troubling phone call; her absence is noted.
Key passages
“She perforated Mr. Penway's spine with her eyes, reduced it to the consistency of summer squash, and drove him before her into the studio.”
She stared at Mr. Penway so intensely that he felt completely intimidated and followed her into the studio.
Describes Mrs. Porter's intimidating presence and psychological dominance.
“How tragic is a man's fruitless fight on behalf of a friend! For one short instant Mrs. Porter allowed Mr. Penway to imagine that the victory was his, then she administered the coup de grâce.”
It is sad when someone tries in vain to defend a friend; Mrs. Porter briefly let Mr. Penway think he had succeeded before revealing the truth.
Highlights the futility of Mr. Penway's lies and Mrs. Porter's strategic cruelty.
“If I may be allowed to say so, madam, I think that there must have been trouble at Mrs. Bannister's.”
Keggs suggests that something serious happened at Mrs. Bannister's house.
Keggs hints at the family crisis that caused Ruth to leave.