The Cloven Foot · Chapter
IX: “And Art Thou Come! and Art Thou True!” explained
Laura Malcolm wrestles with anger and self-reproach over John Treverton's prolonged absence, suspecting he cares only for her fortune.
What happens
Laura Malcolm wrestles with anger and self-reproach over John Treverton's prolonged absence, suspecting he cares only for her fortune. Her bitterness dissolves when John returns, looking ill and careworn, and they reconcile. They walk to the chestnut tree where they parted, and John kneels to propose, confessing his love and unworthiness. Laura accepts him, and they agree to marry to fulfill Jasper Treverton's will, with the Trimmers observing their reunion approvingly.
Themes in this chapter
Love and Marriage
Central to the chapter: Laura's internal conflict over John's absence, their reconciliation, and his proposal under the chestnut tree, leading to their betrothal.
Inheritance and Legitimacy
The marriage is driven by the conditions of Jasper Treverton's will; Laura and John must marry to secure the estate and prevent it from going to a hospital.
Secrets and Deception
John hints at unexplained reasons for his long absence, suggesting hidden circumstances, while Laura suspects he may be insincere about his love.
Characters to notice
- Laura Malcolm
Struggles with anger and self-reproach over John's absence, but forgives him upon his return and accepts his proposal.
- John Treverton
Returns to Hazlehurst after more than half a year, looking ill and careworn; confesses his love and proposes to Laura.
- Trimmer
The butler observes John and Laura at luncheon and remarks to his wife that they seem like man and wife.
- Mrs. Evitt
Mentioned as cook and housekeeper who retorts to Trimmer about Laura's character.
- Edward Clare
Recalled by Laura as having praised her beauty and used the phrase 'not my style.'
Key passages
“After all it is only the fortune he cares about... He is making the most of his last year of liberty.”
Laura convinces herself that John is only interested in her inheritance and is enjoying his freedom before being forced into marriage.
Reveals Laura's deep insecurity and anger about John's motives.
“I will take you, dear, with all your faults, whatever their number. I have a feeling that I can trust you—all the more, perhaps, because you do not praise yourself.”
Laura accepts John's proposal, expressing trust in him despite his self-deprecation.
Marks the turning point where Laura's anger gives way to acceptance and commitment.