The Borough Treasurer · Chapter
Antecedents explained
Brereton decides to investigate Kitely's past and calls Miss Pett to the witness stand.
What happens
Brereton decides to investigate Kitely's past and calls Miss Pett to the witness stand. Her testimony reveals that Kitely was secretive about his life and business, had no known relations, and had made a will leaving his property to her. Brereton's questioning aims to shift suspicion away from Harborough, who remains stubbornly silent about his alibi, insisting that the truth will come out if Brereton delves into Kitely's past.
Themes in this chapter
Secrecy and Blackmail
Kitely's entire life is shrouded in mystery; Miss Pett admits she never knew his business or past, suggesting hidden secrets that may be key to the murder.
Justice and Innocence
Harborough's refusal to provide an alibi and his insistence that the truth will come out highlight the tension between legal procedure and actual innocence.
Characters to notice
- Mr. Brereton
Takes charge of Harborough's defense, cross-examines Miss Pett, and decides to investigate Kitely's background.
- Miss Pett
Kitely's housekeeper for nearly ten years; testifies about Kitely's secretive nature, his lack of relations, and his will leaving property to her.
- John Harborough
Arrested and charged with murder; refuses to reveal his alibi, insisting the truth will emerge from Kitely's past.
- Avice Harborough
Visits Harborough in custody with Brereton; arranges to stay with Mrs. Northrop.
- Christopher Pett
Miss Pett's nephew and solicitor; mentioned as the holder of Kitely's will.
Key passages
“He would act on Avice Harborough’s suggestion, and, while watching the trend of affairs on behalf of the suspected man, would find out all he could about the murdered one.”
Brereton decides to follow Avice's advice: defend Harborough while also investigating Kitely's background.
Brereton's dual strategy of defense and investigation.
“If you want to find out who killed Kitely—go back! Go back, sir—go inch by inch, through Kitely’s life!”
Harborough advises Brereton to investigate Kitely's past thoroughly to uncover the murderer.
Harborough's cryptic suggestion that the key to the murder lies in Kitely's history.