The Autobiography of Mark Rutherford · Chapter
II: Preparation explained
Mark Rutherford describes his training at a Dissenting College to become a minister.
What happens
Mark Rutherford describes his training at a Dissenting College to become a minister. He criticizes the theological education as a sham, the professors as irrelevant, and the students as worldly and shallow. A turning point occurs when he discovers Wordsworth's Lyrical Ballads, which awakens a habit of inner reference and leads him to question orthodoxy. His attempt to reinterpret the atonement in a sermon is met with cold disapproval from the President, deepening his sense of isolation and reserve.
Themes in this chapter
Education and Its Failures
Rutherford condemns the college's theological teaching as a sham, irrelevant to real doubts, and focused on mechanical dogma rather than genuine understanding.
Religious Doubt and Loss of Faith
Rutherford's inner questioning grows as he finds orthodox answers hollow; his discovery of Lyrical Ballads catalyzes a shift away from traditional belief.
Hypocrisy and Authenticity
The President and students are portrayed as worldly and insincere, while Rutherford struggles to express his true self in an environment that rewards conformity.
Characters to notice
- Mark Rutherford
Narrator and protagonist; reflects on his college training, his spiritual awakening through Lyrical Ballads, and his growing alienation from orthodox theology.
- Mr. Catfield
The President of the college; delivers irrelevant lectures, disapproves of Rutherford's sermon, and embodies the shallow orthodoxy Rutherford rejects.
Key passages
“It was a large old-fashioned house with a newer building annexed, and was surrounded with a garden and with meadows.”
The college was an old house with an addition, set in a rural landscape with gardens and fields.
Describes the physical setting of the Dissenting College.
“I remember also some lectures on the proof of the existence of God and on the argument from design; all of which, when my mind was once awakened, were as irrelevant as the chattering of sparrows.”
Lectures on God's existence and design became meaningless to Rutherford once he began to question deeply.
Highlights the irrelevance of the college's theological instruction to Rutherford's growing doubts.
“It excited a movement and a growth which went on till, by degrees, all the systems which enveloped me like a body gradually decayed from me and fell away into nothing.”
Reading Lyrical Ballads sparked an inner transformation that slowly dissolved all the doctrinal systems that had surrounded him.
Describes the profound personal impact of Wordsworth's poetry on Rutherford's spiritual and intellectual development.
“His words fell on me like the hand of a corpse, and I went away much depressed.”
The President's cold criticism felt lifeless and crushing, leaving Rutherford deeply discouraged.
Rutherford's emotional response to the President's rejection of his sermon.