Some Do Not … · Chapter
Chapter III explained
Macmaster reflects on the disastrous day, beginning with Sylvia's letter to Tietjens and ending with General Campion's misplaced praise of Sylvia.
What happens
Macmaster reflects on the disastrous day, beginning with Sylvia's letter to Tietjens and ending with General Campion's misplaced praise of Sylvia. He resolves to urge Tietjens to divorce her. At Rye, Tietjens shows Macmaster Sylvia's letter, then later at the golf club, Tietjens reveals he has sent a telegram agreeing to Sylvia's terms. Macmaster is horrified to learn that Tietjens intends to confront a Liberal Cabinet Minister, Mr. Waterhouse, about a faked return at the office, adding to Macmaster's distress.
Themes in this chapter
Marriage and Adultery
The central conflict revolves around Sylvia's return to Tietjens and Macmaster's insistence on divorce, highlighting the strain in their marriage.
Honor and Reputation
Macmaster believes divorce is necessary for Tietjens' career and decency, while General Campion praises Sylvia's loyalty, showing the importance of public perception.
Loyalty and Betrayal
Macmaster's loyalty to Tietjens is tested as he grapples with Sylvia's letter and Tietjens' actions; Tietjens' plan to confront Waterhouse involves a sense of duty versus betrayal of office norms.
Characters to notice
- Vincent Macmaster
Macmaster is deeply troubled by Sylvia's letter and General Campion's praise of her; he resolves to push Tietjens toward divorce and is later horrified by Tietjens' plan to confront Waterhouse.
- Christopher Tietjens
Tietjens shows Macmaster Sylvia's letter, drinks Burgundy at lunch, and later reveals he has sent a telegram agreeing to Sylvia's return; he intends to confront Mr. Waterhouse about a faked return.
- Sylvia Tietjens
Sylvia's letter to Tietjens is discussed; it states she is ready to return and demands her maid Hullo Central be waiting for her.
- Edith Ethel Duchemin
Macmaster visits the Duchemin rectory and is strongly impressed by Mrs. Duchemin, finding her the most influential woman he has met.
- General Lord Edward Campion
General Campion speaks to Macmaster, praising Sylvia and urging him to get Tietjens back to her, which appalls Macmaster.
- Mr. Waterhouse
The Rt. Hon. Stephen Fenwick Waterhouse is the Liberal Cabinet Minister whom Tietjens plans to confront about a faked return at the office.
- Mr. Sandbach
Sandbach is present at the golf club, described as having a bulldog face and violent manner; he is suspended from Parliament.
- Lady Claudine Sandbach
Lady Claudine is mentioned as having known Sylvia and Tietjens long; General Campion references her in his conversation with Macmaster.
Key passages
“divorce the woman; it was necessary for the peace of mind of himself, of his friends, of his family; for the sake of his career; in the very name of decency!”
Macmaster believed Tietjens must divorce Sylvia for his own peace, his friends, his family, his career, and for decency itself.
Reflects Macmaster's strong conviction about the necessity of divorce.
“The letter had appeared extraordinary in its effrontery, for it said nothing. Beyond the bare statement, 'I am now ready to return to you,' it occupied itself simply with the fact that Mrs. Tietjens wanted—could no longer get on without—the services of her maid, whom she called Hullo Central.”
Sylvia's letter was brazenly empty, stating only that she was ready to return and demanding her maid Hullo Central be waiting.
Highlights Sylvia's manipulative and seemingly indifferent tone.
“Macmaster, who knew the pressure under which his friend must be suffering, thought this reasonable enough, and drove off up Iden Hill by himself.”
Understanding Tietjens' distress, Macmaster accepted his decision to skip the visit and went alone to the Duchemin rectory.
Shows Macmaster's empathy and the strain on Tietjens.
“He said: 'That fellow is the Rt. Hon. Stephen Fenwick Waterhouse. He's chairman of the Funded Debt Commission. He's the swine who made us fake that return in the office.'”
Tietjens identified Waterhouse as the man who forced them to falsify an official return, calling him a swine.
Reveals Tietjens' anger and his sense of duty to confront the issue.