Simon · Chapter
At Stanesland explained
Mr.
What happens
Mr. Carrington visits Ned Cromarty at Stanesland under the pretense of discussing shooting leases, but steers the conversation toward the murder of Sir Reginald Cromarty. He probes Ned's views on the suspicion against Sir Malcolm and Cicely Farmond, declares his certainty of Cicely's innocence, and suggests that Ned hire professional assistance. Later, at tea with Ned's sister Lilian, Carrington subtly draws out information about Ned's recent inheritance. After departing, he sees Cicely Farmond cycling in the dark.
Themes in this chapter
Suspicion and Rumor
Carrington probes Ned's beliefs about the suspects, and the conversation reveals how rumor has implicated Sir Malcolm and Cicely Farmond, despite Ned's fierce denials.
Secrecy and Silence
Ned's inheritance and his refusal to discuss its purpose are hinted at by Lilian, while Carrington's discreet inquiries and satisfied smile suggest hidden knowledge.
Greed and Motive
Carrington emphasizes the lack of motive for the murder, noting that Sir Reginald's death benefits no one financially, while Ned's sudden inheritance raises unspoken questions.
Characters to notice
- F. T. Carrington
Visits Stanesland under the guise of discussing shooting leases, but skillfully steers the conversation toward the murder case, probing Ned's beliefs and gathering information.
- Ned Cromarty
Hosts Carrington at Stanesland; defends Cicely Farmond's innocence passionately, dismisses suspicion against Sir Malcolm, and reveals his inheritance through his sister's complaints.
- Cicely Farmond
Mentioned as the subject of Carrington's certainty of innocence; later seen cycling near Keldale House as Carrington drives home.
- Lilian Cromarty
Ned's sister; complains to Carrington about Ned's refusal to buy a car despite his inheritance, inadvertently revealing financial details.
- James Bisset
Referenced in Carrington's conversation with Ned; Carrington dismisses Bisset's theory about the window entry and notes Bisset's desire to protect the family's reputation.
- Malcolm Cromarty
Discussed as a suspect; Ned calls him 'a bit of a young squirt' but refuses to believe he is a murderer without proof.
Key passages
“Bisset is evidently extremely anxious to save the credit of the family.”
Carrington suggests that Bisset's theory about the window entry is motivated by a desire to protect the family's reputation.
Carrington dismisses Bisset's theory as a face-saving measure.
“I'll stake my life on her innocence!”
Ned declares he is absolutely certain that Cicely Farmond is not guilty.
Ned's passionate defense of Cicely reveals his deep conviction.
“I only wish one could.”
Carrington expresses a wish that a possible motive could be identified.
Carrington's remark underscores the central mystery of the case.
“That's settled anyhow!”
Carrington feels satisfied that he has achieved his objective during the visit.
Carrington's murmured comment indicates he has gathered the information he sought.