Short Fiction · Chapter
III explained
Rutherford and Peggy develop a routine where she visits him after the theatre.
What happens
Rutherford and Peggy develop a routine where she visits him after the theatre. He shares his dream of returning to a quiet life in Worcestershire, while she loves Broadway. Their friendship is strained when Peggy asks about the photograph of Alice Halliday on his mantelpiece, leading to an emotional outburst. She later apologizes but stops visiting, and eventually leaves for Chicago with her show.
Themes in this chapter
Loneliness and Connection
Rutherford and Peggy form a deep emotional bond, but her jealousy and his attachment to Alice create a rift, leaving both isolated.
Love and Marriage
Peggy's jealousy over Alice Halliday and her emotional outburst reveal unspoken romantic feelings for Rutherford.
The Contrast Between City and Country
Rutherford's idealization of rural Worcestershire clashes with Peggy's devotion to Broadway and city life.
Characters to notice
- Rutherford Maxwell
Works diligently on his writing, dreams of returning to Worcestershire, and considers Peggy his mascot.
- Peggy Norton
Visits Rutherford regularly, loves Broadway, becomes jealous of Alice Halliday, and has an emotional breakdown before leaving for Chicago.
- Gladys
Mentioned as having visited once with Peggy but the visit was not a success.
Key passages
“Gee, George, don't you ever let up for a second? Seems to me you write all the time.”
Peggy expresses amazement at Rutherford's constant writing.
Highlights Rutherford's dedication to his craft.
“Way over in England, Peggy, there's a county called Worcestershire. And somewhere near the edge of that there's a grey house with gables...”
Rutherford describes his dream of a peaceful life in the English countryside.
Illustrates the contrast between his ideal and Peggy's urban preferences.
“I hate you! I do! I wish I'd never seen you!”
Peggy angrily declares her hatred for Rutherford after asking about Alice.
Shows her jealousy and emotional turmoil.