Short Fiction · Chapter
III explained
Professor Kesserich quizzes Jack on the concept of individuality, discussing heredity, environment, and the theoretical possibility of duplicating a person through controlled genetics and environment.
What happens
Professor Kesserich quizzes Jack on the concept of individuality, discussing heredity, environment, and the theoretical possibility of duplicating a person through controlled genetics and environment. Jack is unsettled by the implications, and Kesserich hints at a secret project while mentioning he will be busy the next day.
Themes in this chapter
Identity and Illusion
The chapter explores the nature of individuality and the possibility of recreating a person through control of heredity and environment, questioning what makes someone unique.
Science and Ethics
Kesserich's speculative discussion about duplicating individuals raises ethical concerns about manipulating life and identity.
Characters to notice
- Jack Barr
Jack is the student being questioned by Kesserich; he feels uneasy and tries to avoid mentioning his earlier conversation with Mrs. Kesserich.
- Mrs. Kesserich
Mrs. Kesserich leaves the room with an anxious glance at Jack, worried he might reveal their private conversation.
- Martin Kesserich
Professor Kesserich leads a speculative discussion on individuality and hints at a secret project, while noting he will be busy the next day.
Key passages
“Suppose—this is just speculation—that we could control heredity and environment. Then we could recreate the same individual at will.”
Kesserich speculates that if we could control genetics and surroundings, we could make an exact copy of a person.
This introduces the central philosophical and scientific question of the chapter.
“Newman tells about a pair of identical twins separated from birth, unaware of each other’s existence. They met by accident when they were twenty-one. Each was a telephone repairman. Each had a wife the same age. Each had a baby son. And each had a fox terrier called ‘Trixie.’”
Kesserich cites a case of identical twins raised apart who ended up with remarkably similar lives, suggesting environment may be less influential than thought.
This anecdote supports Kesserich's argument about the power of heredity.