Poetry · Chapter
CXXXI explained
The speaker addresses the Dark Lady, acknowledging her tyrannical beauty and the conflict between public opinion and his own adoration.
What happens
The speaker addresses the Dark Lady, acknowledging her tyrannical beauty and the conflict between public opinion and his own adoration. He admits that others find her unattractive, but he swears to himself that she is the fairest, though her deeds are black, which gives rise to slander.
Themes in this chapter
Truth and Deception
The speaker grapples with the disparity between public perception and his private truth, swearing to himself that the Dark Lady is fairest despite others' claims.
Lust and Morality
The Dark Lady's 'black deeds' suggest moral corruption, yet the speaker's desire persists, highlighting the tension between lust and ethical judgment.
Characters to notice
- William Shakespeare
The speaker, expressing conflicted devotion to the Dark Lady.
- Love
Personified as the force that makes the speaker groan in adoration.
Key passages
“Thou art as tyrannous, so as thou art, As those whose beauties proudly make them cruel;”
You are as tyrannical as those whose beauty makes them arrogantly cruel.
The speaker compares the Dark Lady's beauty-driven cruelty to that of other proud beauties.
“In nothing art thou black save in thy deeds, And thence this slander, as I think, proceeds.”
You are not black in any way except in your actions, and I believe that is the source of the slander against you.
The speaker defends the Dark Lady's appearance but condemns her immoral actions, which cause others to speak ill of her.