Phineas Redux · Chapter
Seventy-Two explained
Phineas Finn delivers a speech in the House of Commons defending himself against accusations of inconsistency, particularly the charge made by Mr.
What happens
Phineas Finn delivers a speech in the House of Commons defending himself against accusations of inconsistency, particularly the charge made by Mr. Bonteen. He alludes to his past resignation and his foresight on a measure now passed. Despite the speech's success in provoking Conservative wrath, Phineas feels isolated from his party and anxious about his political future. He consults Lord Cantrip about the correspondence with Bonteen, but receives no reassurance about his prospects. The chapter ends with the Government being defeated by a majority of 72.
Themes in this chapter
Political Ambition and Compromise
Phineas's anxiety about his political future and his struggle to reconcile his past actions with his current ambitions highlight the compromises and uncertainties of political life.
The Cost of Ambition
Phineas's isolation and emotional turmoil, despite his successful speech, underscore the personal sacrifices and loneliness that accompany political ambition.
Scandal and Public Opinion
The correspondence between Phineas and Bonteen becomes a topic of club gossip, and Phineas fears its impact on his reputation and prospects.
Characters to notice
- Phineas Finn
Delivers a speech defending himself, alludes to his past resignation, and feels anxious and isolated from his party.
- Mr. Bonteen
His charge against Phineas is the subject of the speech and the subsequent correspondence shown to Lord Fawn.
- Lord Cantrip
Phineas consults him about the correspondence with Bonteen; he is kind but offers no hint about future government positions.
- Mr. Gresham
Phineas observes him in the House but exchanges no words; Phineas feels Mr. Gresham has ungraciously abstained from recognizing him.
- Mr. Monk
Speaks a kind word to Phineas before his speech.
- Barrington Erle
Says a few good-natured words to Phineas after the speech.
Key passages
“He was wretchedly anxious, and angry with himself for his own anxiety. He scorned to say a word that should sound like an entreaty; and yet he had placed his whole heart on a thing which seemed to be slipping from him for the want of asking.”
Phineas was miserably worried and frustrated with his own worry. He refused to beg for what he wanted, but his deepest desire was slipping away because he wouldn't ask.
Illustrates Phineas's internal conflict between pride and desperation over his political future.
“He had given up everything in the world with the view of getting into office; and now that the opportunity had come—an opportunity which if allowed to slip could hardly return again in time to be of service to him—the prize was to elude his grasp!”
He had sacrificed everything to gain a government position, and now that the chance was here—a chance that might not come again soon—the reward was about to escape him.
Highlights the high stakes and Phineas's sense of impending failure.
“At five o’clock in the morning the division took place, and the Government was beaten by a majority of 72. This was much higher than any man had expected.”
The vote happened at 5 a.m., and the Government lost by 72 votes, a much larger margin than anyone anticipated.
Marks a decisive political turning point in the chapter.