Phineas Redux · Chapter
Two Days Before the Trial explained
Phineas Finn, imprisoned for murder, meets with his defense counsel Mr.
What happens
Phineas Finn, imprisoned for murder, meets with his defense counsel Mr. Chaffanbrass and insists on a bold, truth-based defense rather than legal quibbling. Mr. Chaffanbrass reflects on the nature of criminal law and the difficulty of proving innocence. Lord Fawn is brought in to examine a coat, but the evidence remains circumstantial. Phineas struggles with the social condemnation more than the fear of death.
Themes in this chapter
Justice and Injustice
Phineas feels deeply wronged by the accusation and the public's condemnation, while Mr. Chaffanbrass discusses the fallibility of legal proof.
Friendship and Loyalty
Lord Chiltern and Mr. Low visit Phineas regularly, and the Duchess, Lady Chiltern, and Lady Laura send him provisions.
Scandal and Public Opinion
Phineas is more tormented by the social disgrace than by the prospect of execution.
Characters to notice
- Phineas Finn
Imprisoned and preparing for trial, he insists on a defense based on truth and rejects legal quibbling.
- Mr. Chaffanbrass
Defense counsel who interviews Phineas and reflects on the nature of criminal law and evidence.
- Lord Fawn
Brought in to examine a coat as potential evidence, but his testimony is inconclusive.
- Mr. Wickerby
Attorney who arranges the meeting between Phineas and Mr. Chaffanbrass.
- Mr. Scruby
Clerk who puts on the coat for examination during the legal preparations.
- Lord Chiltern
Frequent visitor to Phineas in prison, a loyal friend.
Key passages
“I would have you hurl defiance at my accusers.”
Phineas wants his defense to boldly challenge the accusations against him.
Phineas insists on an aggressive, truth-based defense.
“It is the condemnation of those who had known him that was so terrible to him.”
Phineas fears the judgment of his peers more than death itself.
The social stigma of being thought a murderer is his greatest torment.