Relief explained

What happens

Themes in this chapter

• Detection and Investigation

  Mr. Gryce's methodical plan succeeds through tracking William's footsteps; the chapter highlights the process of elimination and shifting suspicion.

• Secrecy and Deception

  The Knollys family's hidden secrets—William's vivisection and the mother's return and death—are exposed, yet Mr. Gryce agrees to keep them confidential.

Characters to notice

• Amelia Butterworth

  Narrates the chapter; feels relief and gladness that the investigation has failed, revealing her compassion beyond the detective instinct.

• Mr. Gryce

  Executes the plan successfully, conducts a second search, and reassures the sisters that their secrets will remain private; confirms the investigation will now focus on Mother Jane's cottage.

• William Knollys

  Unwittingly reveals the location of hidden evidence by his footsteps; later returns angry, blaming his sisters for exposing his vivisection and declaring he will play detective.

• Lucetta

  Present during the events; dismisses Hannah's fears, stating the worst secret is already out.

• Hannah

  Rushes in to announce the return of the police with spades and lanterns.

Key passages

• “The plan succeeded. Mr. Gryce’s plans usually do.”

  Mr. Gryce's scheme worked, as his schemes typically do.

  Opening line establishing Gryce's competence.

• “Your part has been well played, but I know you are glad that it has failed.”

  You performed your role admirably, but I know you're relieved it didn't succeed.

  Mr. Gryce acknowledges Miss Butterworth's mixed feelings about the investigation's outcome.

• “I’m going to see if I cannot make folks blink askance at some other man than me. I’m going to find out who or what causes these disappearances.”

  I intend to divert suspicion from myself by investigating the real cause of the disappearances.

  William declares his intention to play detective, shifting focus from his own secrets.