Howards End · Chapter
Chapter XVI explained
The chapter explores the tension between the Schlegel sisters and Leonard Bast, as well as the Wilcoxes' judgmental attitudes.
What happens
The chapter explores the tension between the Schlegel sisters and Leonard Bast, as well as the Wilcoxes' judgmental attitudes. Margaret and Helen attempt to connect with Leonard on an intellectual and personal level, but their efforts backfire when Leonard feels patronized and explodes in anger. Mr. Wilcox and Evie observe the scene, reinforcing class prejudices. The chapter highlights the clash between idealism and social reality, and the difficulty of bridging class divides.
Themes in this chapter
Social Class and Inequality
The chapter dramatizes the difficulty of cross-class friendship, as Leonard Bast feels patronized and the Wilcoxes reinforce class distinctions.
Connection vs. Isolation
The Schlegels' attempt to connect with Leonard fails, leading to mutual misunderstanding and isolation.
Materialism vs. Idealism
Leonard's desire for intellectual and spiritual meaning clashes with the practical, business-oriented world of the Wilcoxes and the Schlegels' well-meaning but clumsy idealism.
Characters to notice
- Margaret Schlegel
Defends Leonard Bast's character to Mr. Wilcox, attempts to mediate the conflict, and reflects on the failure of the encounter.
- Helen Schlegel
Shows sympathy for Leonard Bast, calls him 'poor dear Mr. Bast,' and tries to help him despite the awkward situation.
- Henry Wilcox
Criticizes the Schlegels' impracticality, feels jealousy over Margaret's defense of Leonard, and later offers condescending advice.
- Evie Wilcox
Dislikes Margaret, dismisses Leonard as 'not our sort,' and is attracted to Mr. Percy Cahill.
- Leonard Bast
Feels patronized and exploited by the Schlegels, angrily accuses them of picking his brain, and leaves in frustration.
Key passages
“Love, say the ascetics, reveals our shameful kinship with the beasts. Be it so: one can bear that; jealousy is the real shame.”
Ascetics claim love exposes our animal nature, but jealousy is far more degrading.
Reflects on Mr. Wilcox's jealousy and the theme of connection vs. isolation.
“We tried knowing another class—impossible.”
We attempted to bridge the class divide, but it proved impossible.
Leonard's bitter conclusion about the failed friendship, highlighting social class and inequality.
“What is the good of your stars and trees, your sunrise and the wind, if they do not enter into our daily lives?”
What value do nature and beauty have if they don't connect to everyday existence?
Margaret's plea for integrating idealism with practical life, central to materialism vs. idealism.