How to Tell the Birds from the Flowers and Other Woodcuts · Chapter
The Roc; The Shamrock explained
The author expresses skepticism about the mythical Roc from Sinbad's tales, considering it a sham, and notes that the shamrock is associated with St.
What happens
The author expresses skepticism about the mythical Roc from Sinbad's tales, considering it a sham, and notes that the shamrock is associated with St. Patrick's Day.
Themes in this chapter
Wordplay and Homophones
The chapter plays on the homophonic similarity between 'Roc' and 'shamrock', linking a mythical bird to a plant.
Cultural and Literary Reference
References Sinbad's Roc from Arabian Nights and the shamrock from St. Patrick's Day, blending literary and cultural symbols.
Key passages
“Although I never took much stock, In Sinbad’s yarn about the Roc, And really must confess I am Inclined to think the Roc a sham”
I never believed Sinbad's story about the Roc, and I admit I think the Roc is a fake.
Expresses doubt about the mythical bird's existence.
“Take notice that, the Sham‑rock may Be seen upon St. Patrick’s day.”
Note that the shamrock can be seen on St. Patrick's Day.
Contrasts the mythical Roc with the real shamrock associated with a holiday.