Essays · Chapter
I: Qualities of the Recruit explained
Thoreau explores the nature of true bravery and virtue, contrasting the courageous man—who is self-reliant, spherical in character, and aligned with the divine—with the coward, who is flat, dependent on external creeds, and lacks inner fort
What happens
Thoreau explores the nature of true bravery and virtue, contrasting the courageous man—who is self-reliant, spherical in character, and aligned with the divine—with the coward, who is flat, dependent on external creeds, and lacks inner fortitude. He argues that fortitude turns all to good fortune, and that necessity is a flexible, benevolent force.
Themes in this chapter
Individualism and Self-Reliance
The brave man is self-contained, relying on his own virtue and inner divinity rather than external creeds or devices.
Heroism and Moral Courage
True heroism is defined by inner fortitude, not outward action; the brave man is spherical, strong in all directions, and aligned with necessity.
Characters to notice
- Henry David Thoreau
Author and narrator; expounds on the qualities of the brave man and the coward.
- Virgil
Quoted at the opening: 'Spes sibi quisque' (Each one his own hope).
- The Hero
Referenced as the sixth champion against Thebes, bearing a shield with no device.
- The Soul
Described as the ordering, right-handed distributor of all fates.
Key passages
“The brave man is the elder son of creation, who has stepped buoyantly into his inheritance, while the coward, who is the younger, waiteth patiently till he decease.”
The courageous person actively claims his rightful place in life, whereas the timid person passively waits for death.
Thoreau contrasts the proactive bravery of the self-reliant individual with the passive cowardice of the dependent.
“He does not present a gleaming edge to ward off harm, for that will oftenest attract the lightning, but rather is the all-pervading ether, which the lightning does not strike but purify.”
The brave man does not aggressively defend himself, as that invites trouble; instead, he is like the atmosphere that lightning purifies rather than damages.
Thoreau uses a natural metaphor to illustrate non-resistance and inner strength.
“For an impenetrable shield, stand inside yourself; he was no artist, but an artisan, who first made shields of brass.”
The best defense is self-reliance; the first maker of brass shields was merely a craftsman, not a true artist.
Thoreau emphasizes inner virtue over external protection.