Short Works · Chapter
Chapter LXIII explained
A concise maxim contrasting the consequences of just versus unjust judgment, prioritizing the approval of nature and one's own conscience over the misplaced blame of others.
What happens
A concise maxim contrasting the consequences of just versus unjust judgment, prioritizing the approval of nature and one's own conscience over the misplaced blame of others.
Themes in this chapter
Virtue as the Only Good
The chapter defines a just judgment as the virtuous action, which is inherently good regardless of external blame, while an unjust judgment is a vice, inherently bad even if praised by others.
Dichotomy of Control
It distinguishes between what is 'up to us' (making a just judgment) and what is not (the undeserved blame from the condemned), advising to focus solely on the former.
Key passages
“It is better when you judge justly to be blamed undeservedly by him who has been condemned than when you judge unjustly to be justly blamed by (before) nature.”
It is preferable to perform your duty with justice and face unfair criticism from the person you ruled against, than to act unjustly and earn the rightful condemnation of the natural order (or your own conscience).
Emphasizes that the true standard of judgment is not human opinion, but alignment with nature and virtue.