Clouds of Witness · Chapter
VI: Mary Quite Contrary explained
The Grand Jury indicts the Duke of Denver for murder.
What happens
The Grand Jury indicts the Duke of Denver for murder. Charles Parker returns from Paris and meets Lord Peter at his flat. They analyze Lady Mary's inconsistent story about the night of the murder, concluding that she was expecting to meet someone else (No. 10) and hid a suitcase. A telegram arrives indicating a suspect has been traced to London.
Themes in this chapter
Deception and Secrets
Lady Mary's deceptive story and hidden suitcase reveal layers of secrecy surrounding the murder.
Family Loyalty and Honor
Lady Mary's actions inadvertently implicate her brother, highlighting the conflict between protecting a loved one and the truth.
Justice and the Legal System
The indictment of the Duke and the legal technicalities of trying a peer underscore the intersection of class and justice.
Characters to notice
- Lord Peter Wimsey
Returns to his flat and discusses the case with Parker, analyzing Lady Mary's behavior and receiving a telegram about a traced suspect.
- Mr. Parker
Returns from Paris, meets Wimsey, and works through the evidence, theorizing about Lady Mary's actions and the mysterious No. 10.
- Lady Mary Wimsey
Her inconsistent story and behavior are analyzed; she is suspected of hiding a suitcase and meeting someone on the night of the murder.
- Bunter
Opens the door for Parker and offers tea; later delivers a telegram to Wimsey.
- Gerald Wimsey
Indicted for murder by the Grand Jury and produced in court, but the judge declares himself incompetent to try a peer.
- Mrs. Pettigrew-Robinson
Mentioned for her testimony about a door slamming on the landing, which becomes key evidence.
Key passages
“I am striving to take into public life what any man gets from his mother. Lady Astor”
Lady Astor expresses her aim to bring maternal values into public life.
Epigraph setting a thematic tone for the chapter.
“The glassblower's cat is bompstable”
Parker mutters a nonsensical phrase while half-asleep.
Highlights Parker's drowsy state and his interrupted train of thought.
“Hell! I'll have the truth of this beastly business if we all go to the gallows together!”
Wimsey vows to uncover the truth regardless of the consequences.
Shows Wimsey's determination and frustration with the case.