Barnaby Rudge · Chapter
Chapter 58 explained
Barnaby is taken to the barracks and confined in a dark cell.
What happens
Barnaby is taken to the barracks and confined in a dark cell. He overhears two soldiers discussing his fate, one of whom suggests he should be shot without a magistrate's intervention. Barnaby pleads for his pet raven Grip, but is ignored. He is later marched back to the parade ground where he is held among a larger body of soldiers.
Themes in this chapter
Freedom and Imprisonment
Barnaby's physical confinement in a dark cell contrasts with his mental wanderings and his plea for Grip's freedom.
The Spectacle of Death
The soldiers' casual talk of shooting Barnaby without trial highlights the dehumanizing spectacle of punishment during the riots.
Characters to notice
- Barnaby Rudge
Imprisoned in a dark cell, he pleads for his raven Grip and shows defiance toward the soldiers.
- Grip
Barnaby's pet raven, mentioned as being held by the soldiers and the subject of Barnaby's plea.
- Hugh
Referenced in Barnaby's half-dream, where he imagines Hugh speaking to him in the stable.
Key passages
“It makes a man sorrowful to come back to old England, and see her in this condition.”
Returning to England and seeing it in such a state is deeply saddening.
A soldier reflects on the sorry state of the country during the riots.
“You talk boldly to a caged man... If I was on the other side of the door and there were none to part us, you'd change your note.”
You speak bravely to a prisoner; if I were free and we were alone, you would speak differently.
Barnaby defiantly responds to the sergeant's threats.