Barchester Towers · Chapter
Slope Versus Harding explained
Mr.
What happens
Mr. Slope meets with Mr. Harding to discuss the terms of the warden's appointment at Hiram's Hospital, imposing new duties and conditions that Mr. Harding ultimately rejects, leading Slope to report the refusal to the bishop and Mrs. Proudie, who then consider Mr. Quiverful as a replacement.
Themes in this chapter
Clerical Corruption and Patronage
Mr. Slope and Mrs. Proudie manipulate the appointment process for Hiram's Hospital, prioritizing political and personal gain over merit.
Tradition vs. Reform
Mr. Harding represents the old, easy-going clerical tradition, while Mr. Slope embodies the new, demanding reformist approach.
Personal Integrity vs. Ambition
Mr. Harding's refusal to accept conditions he disagrees with contrasts with Mr. Slope's ambitious maneuvering to secure the position for an ally.
Characters to notice
- Mr. Slope
Conducts the interview with Mr. Harding, imposing new conditions for the hospital appointment and reporting the refusal to the bishop.
- Mr. Harding
Listens to Mr. Slope's proposed duties, becomes angry, and ultimately declines the appointment under the proposed conditions.
- Dr. Proudie
Mentioned as the bishop who supports the new measures and is informed of Mr. Harding's refusal.
- Mrs. Proudie
Influences the bishop's decision, suggesting Mr. Quiverful as a more suitable candidate.
- Mr. Quiverful
Mentioned as a potential replacement for the hospital appointment.
Key passages
“New men, Mr. Harding, are now needed and are now forthcoming in the church, as well as in other professions.”
Mr. Slope asserts that the church requires a new generation of clergy who are active and reform-minded, unlike the old guard.
Highlights the ideological clash between tradition and reform.
“I will take an early opportunity of seeing his lordship myself.”
Mr. Harding insists on speaking directly to the bishop rather than negotiating through Mr. Slope.
Shows Mr. Harding's resistance to Mr. Slope's authority and his desire for direct communication.
“I shall consult my friends in this matter, Mr. Slope; but I mean to be guilty of no subterfuge—you may tell the bishop that as I altogether disagree with his views about the hospital, I shall decline the situation if I find that any such conditions are attached to it as those you have suggested.”
Mr. Harding states he will seek advice but clearly refuses the appointment if the proposed conditions are mandatory.
Demonstrates Mr. Harding's principled stand and his rejection of the new terms.