Anne of the Island · Chapter
XII: “Averil’s Atonement” explained
Anne writes a story titled 'Averil’s Atonement', sharing it with Diana and Mr.
What happens
Anne writes a story titled 'Averil’s Atonement', sharing it with Diana and Mr. Harrison for critique. Despite their feedback and her own revisions, the story is rejected by two magazines. Anne initially despairs over her literary ambitions but eventually resolves to focus on teaching after Redmond.
Themes in this chapter
Ambition and Career
Anne pursues her dream of becoming a published author, facing rejection and learning from criticism.
Self-Discovery
Through writing and rejection, Anne discovers her limitations and re-evaluates her future path.
Friendship
Diana’s unwavering support and Mr. Harrison’s blunt advice highlight the role of friends in Anne’s creative journey.
Characters to notice
- Anne Shirley
Writes and revises her story 'Averil’s Atonement', receives rejections, and temporarily abandons literary ambitions.
- Diana Barry
Supports Anne’s writing, offers enthusiastic feedback, and names the character Robert Ray.
- Mr. Harrison
Critiques Anne’s story harshly, advises her to write about familiar people and places, and suggests she not give up writing.
- Gilbert Blythe
Anne tells him about the story but does not read it to him.
- Marilla Cuthbert
Unaware of Anne’s writing venture; Anne imagines reading the story to her.
Key passages
“This is the end of my literary ambitions.”
Anne declares she will stop writing stories after two rejections.
Reflects Anne's initial despair and sense of finality.
“I wouldn't give up altogether... I'd write of people and places like I knew, and I'd make my characters talk everyday English.”
Mr. Harrison advises Anne to write about familiar subjects and use natural dialogue.
Key advice that influences Anne's later writing approach.
“You may name the little hired boy who lived with the Lesters.”
Anne allows Diana to name a minor character in the story.
Shows the collaborative and playful nature of their friendship.