A Man Could Stand Up— · Chapter
I explained
Valentine Wannop attempts to telephone her mother to announce her intention to live with Christopher Tietjens, but the line is dead.
What happens
Valentine Wannop attempts to telephone her mother to announce her intention to live with Christopher Tietjens, but the line is dead. She reflects on her mother's work and the Victorian attitudes toward irregular unions. She enters Tietjens' empty house, encounters the hostile Captain Mckechnie, and overhears his accusations about Tietjens, Sylvia, and Campion. She discovers a penciled note from Tietjens reading 'A man could stand up on a bleedin' 'ill!' and a letter from Sylvia about furniture. The telephone rings; it is her mother. Valentine confesses she must live with Tietjens, though she admits she does not yet know if he is sane.
Themes in this chapter
Waiting and Inaction
Valentine repeatedly reflects on waiting—waiting for the telephone, waiting for Tietjens, waiting for her mother's response—highlighting the theme of inaction.
Gender Roles and Independence
Valentine's decision to live with Tietjens without marriage challenges conventional gender roles; her mother's work as a writer also defies traditional expectations.
Madness and Sanity
Tietjens is described as 'quite noticeably mad' by Valentine, and she questions his sanity; Mckechnie's behavior also suggests instability.
Characters to notice
- Valentine Wannop
Protagonist of the chapter; she goes to Tietjens' house to tell her mother of her decision to live with him, reflects on her mother's work, and confronts Mckechnie.
- Christopher Tietjens
Absent but central; Valentine observes his empty house, his sold furniture, and finds his penciled note; she is uncertain of his sanity.
- Captain Mckechnie
Appears at the door, hostile and unshaven; he accuses Tietjens and Campion of conspiracy and claims to have been dismissed from the Army.
- Mrs. Wannop
Valentine's mother; she is a writer working on a novel and a women's history of the War; Valentine telephones her to announce her decision.
- Edith Ethel Duchemin
Mentioned in Valentine's thoughts; she had a high-minded liaison with Macmaster and accused Valentine of having a child by Tietjens.
- Sylvia Tietjens
Mentioned in Mckechnie's accusations and in the letter Valentine sees; she is removing furniture from Tietjens' house.
Key passages
“Waiting! Waiting! How much of one's life wasn't spent waiting, with one's weight boring one's heels into the ground.”
Valentine reflects on how much of life is consumed by waiting, feeling the physical weight of inaction.
Highlights the theme of waiting and inaction as Valentine waits for the telephone to work.
“A man could stand up on a bleedin' 'ill!”
Tietjens' penciled note expresses the idea that a man can find a place of stability and freedom.
This note gives Valentine hope and symbolizes the possibility of a new life together.
“I believe that I shall die if I cannot live with him.”
Valentine tells her mother that living without Tietjens feels unbearable, as if it would kill her.
Shows the depth of Valentine's commitment and emotional dependence on Tietjens.