A Farewell to Arms · Chapter
XV explained
Frederic Henry undergoes medical consultations and X-rays for his leg wounds.
What happens
Frederic Henry undergoes medical consultations and X-rays for his leg wounds. After being examined by cautious doctors who recommend a six-month wait before surgery, he insists on a second opinion. Dr. Valentini, a confident and cheerful major, agrees to operate the next morning.
Themes in this chapter
Courage and Cowardice
Frederic's insistence on immediate surgery despite risks contrasts with the cautious, conservative approach of the first captain.
War and Disillusionment
The grim reality of war wounds and the bureaucratic, often ineffective medical system reflect the disillusionment of the era.
Characters to notice
- Frederic Henry
The wounded protagonist, impatient with medical delays and eager for surgery.
- Catherine Barkley
Brings Frederic his X-ray plates and shares a brief, tender moment with him.
- Miss Gage
Assists with dressings and is present during the doctor's visit.
- Dr. Valentini
A cheerful, confident major who agrees to operate on Frederic's knee the next morning.
Key passages
“I have noticed that doctors who fail in the practice of medicine have a tendency to seek one another’s company and aid in consultation.”
Frederic observes that incompetent doctors often band together for consultations.
Reflects Frederic's cynical view of the medical profession.
“I want it cut off, so I can wear a hook on it.”
Frederic sarcastically says he wants his leg amputated to use a hook.
Shows his frustration with the doctors' recommendation to wait six months.