# In Which Two Lights Are Put Out explained — Vanity Fair

> Chapter companion for Vanity Fair by William Makepeace Thackeray.

## What happens

The chapter recounts the death of old John Sedley, following shortly after the death of his wife. His final days are marked by a reconciliation with his daughter Amelia, who nurses him devotedly. After his death, the contrast between a prosperous life and a humble, penitent end is reflected upon. Meanwhile, old Mr. Osborne begins to acknowledge Major Dobbin's rising reputation, and Amelia finds the genteel society of her in-laws oppressive, welcoming a proposed foreign tour.

## Themes in this chapter

### Wealth and Poverty

The chapter contrasts the worldly success of a wealthy man with the humble, penitent end of old John Sedley, questioning which is the better lot.

### Family and Betrayal

Amelia's devoted care for her father heals a long-standing family feud, highlighting the complexities of filial duty and reconciliation.

### Appearance vs. Reality

Old Mr. Osborne's changing view of Major Dobbin's reputation illustrates how social perception can shift with public recognition.

## Character check-ins

### John Sedley

Dies after a period of illness, reconciled with his daughter Amelia, and leaves a humble legacy.

### Amelia Sedley

Devotedly nurses her father in his final days, achieving a tacit reconciliation with him.

### Joseph Sedley

Retreats to the Star and Garter after his father's death, avoiding the house.

### William Dobbin

Attends the funeral and is increasingly recognized for his merit and reputation.

### George Osborne

Attends his grandfather's funeral and is noted by old Mr. Osborne.

### Mr. Osborne

Begins to acknowledge Major Dobbin's social standing and reputation.

## Key lines

> The old man clung to his daughter during this sickness. He would take his broths and medicines from scarcely any other hand.

In his final illness, John Sedley relied almost exclusively on Amelia for his care and nourishment.

_Highlights Amelia's devoted nursing and the deepening bond between father and daughter._

> Old Sedley forgot these charges as he was making up his last account, and did justice to the gentle and uncomplaining little martyr.

As he faced death, John Sedley set aside his past grievances and recognized Amelia's quiet, selfless devotion.

_Illustrates the theme of reconciliation and the re-evaluation of family relationships at life's end._

> Which, I wonder, brother reader, is the better lot, to die prosperous and famous, or poor and disappointed?

The narrator poses a moral question about whether it is better to die wealthy and renowned or in humble obscurity.

_Directly addresses the theme of wealth and poverty and the value of a humble, penitent life._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/vanity_fair_se/chapters/lxi-in-which-two-lights-are-put-out
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/vanity_fair_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/vanity_fair_se/chapters