# In Which President Barbicane Says No More Than Suits His Purpose explained — Topsy-Turvy

> Chapter companion for Topsy-Turvy by Jules Verne.

## What happens

President Barbicane addresses a meeting of the Gun Club and stockholders, revealing the N.P.P.A.'s plan to exploit Arctic coal fields. He asserts that the Arctic is a solid continent, not an ice ocean, and hints at a revolutionary mechanical device to remove the North Pole. Despite pressure from European delegates, Barbicane withholds the full secret, eventually disclosing that the plan involves shifting the Earth's axis to melt polar ice, with calculations credited to J. T. Maston.

## Themes in this chapter

### Scientific Hubris

Barbicane's audacious plan to shift the Earth's axis reflects overconfidence in human engineering to dominate natural forces.

### Imperialism and National Rivalry

The N.P.P.A.'s purchase of Arctic regions and Barbicane's assertion of U.S. ownership provoke tension with European delegates, highlighting national competition for resources.

### Capitalism and Speculation

The meeting emphasizes the commercial exploitation of Arctic coal fields, with promises of unprecedented dividends to stockholders.

## Character check-ins

### President Barbicane

Delivers a persuasive speech to stockholders and European delegates, revealing the N.P.P.A.'s plan to exploit Arctic coal and shift the Earth's axis, while strategically withholding key details.

### J. T. Maston

Credited by Barbicane as the brilliant calculator behind the plan to move the North Pole; acknowledged with cheers from the audience, deeply moving Mrs. Scorbitt.

### Major Donellan

Represents England and challenges Barbicane with pointed questions about the feasibility and means of reaching the North Pole, pressing for specifics.

### Eric Baldenak

Expresses skepticism about Barbicane's claims regarding the Arctic continent, demanding certainty rather than supposition.

### Dean Toodrink

Makes sarcastic remarks about the Gun Club's past moon project, interrupting Barbicane's speech with mockery.

### Mrs. Evangelina Scorbitt

Deeply touched by the public recognition of J. T. Maston, for whom she has strong feelings.

## Key lines

> Archimedes only asked for a lever to lift the world. Well, this lever we have found. We are now in a position to remove the North Pole.

Barbicane compares their plan to Archimedes' lever, claiming they have the means to move the North Pole itself.

_Highlights the grand ambition and scientific hubris of the N.P.P.A.'s scheme._

> It is the sun which will take upon himself the melting of the icebergs and fields around the North Pole, and thus make access to the same very easy. So, as people cannot go to the pole, the pole will come to them.

Barbicane explains that by shifting the Earth's axis, the sun will melt the polar ice, bringing the pole to explorers rather than requiring them to reach it.

_Summarizes the core of Barbicane's plan and its reliance on natural forces._

> We have the means of making a new one which will hereafter regulate the routine of day and night.

Barbicane claims they can create a new axis for Earth, altering the cycle of day and night.

_Reveals the extent of the proposed modification to Earth's rotation._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/topsy_turvy_se/chapters/in-which-president-barbicane-says-no-more-than-suits-his-purpose
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/topsy_turvy_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/topsy_turvy_se/chapters