# With Malice Aforethought explained — The Virginian

> Chapter companion for The Virginian by Owen Wister.

## What happens

The Virginian and Molly ride together, but she is hurt by his earlier secrecy about his conflict with Trampas. He breaks his personal code to explain the quarrel, though he veils it in humor. The town buzzes with talk of the impending showdown. The bishop urges the Virginian to tell Molly everything, but he hesitates, torn between his love and his sense of honor. Molly senses the danger and tries to draw him out, but he deflects with irony. She feels the shift in their relationship, now knowing he is both her worshipper and her master.

## Themes in this chapter

### Code of the West

The Virginian's personal code—never to speak ill of a man to a woman—is broken for Molly's sake, showing the conflict between honor and love.

### Justice and Vigilantism

The town discusses the impending showdown with Trampas, and the bishop grapples with the moral implications of extrajudicial violence.

### Love and Romance

Molly's loneliness and her deepening bond with the Virginian are central, as she struggles to accept his world and his secrets.

## Character check-ins

### The Virginian

Struggles with his code of silence, tries to protect Molly from the ugliness of his quarrel with Trampas, and faces the moral dilemma of the impending showdown.

### Molly Stark Wood

Feels lonely and hurt by the Virginian's secrecy, but tries to hide her feelings; she senses the danger and attempts to understand his world.

### Trampas

The antagonist whose presence looms over the chapter; he is seen riding ahead and is the subject of the town's gossip about the coming confrontation.

### Bishop of Wyoming

Meets the Virginian and advises him to tell Molly the truth; he is torn between his Christian duty and his sympathy for the Virginian's position.

### Monte

The Virginian's horse, mentioned as they ride together and during the snake-shooting scene.

## Key lines

> It was his code never to speak ill of any man to any woman. Men’s quarrels were not for women’s ears.

He believed that women should be shielded from the harsh realities of men's conflicts.

_Highlights the Virginian's adherence to the Code of the West and his protective attitude toward Molly._

> I want to do right today more than any day I have ever lived.

He feels an intense pressure to act honorably on his wedding day.

_Reveals the Virginian's internal struggle between his sense of duty and his love for Molly._

> She knew her cowboy lover, with all that he lacked, to be more than ever she could be, with all that she had. He was her worshipper still, but her master, too.

Molly realizes that despite her superior upbringing, the Virginian has become her equal and even her guide.

_Captures the shift in power dynamics in their relationship as Molly submits to his strength._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_virginian_se/chapters/xxxv-with-malice-aforethought
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_virginian_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_virginian_se/chapters