# XIII: Questioning explained — The Portent

> Chapter companion for The Portent by George MacDonald.

## What happens

Duncan Campbell, overwhelmed by the new life and love he feels for Lady Alice, struggles to maintain composure. After a week of absence, Lady Alice returns to him in her sleep. Upon waking, they discuss their situation. Lady Alice reveals that Lord and Lady Hilton are her stepmother and her husband, and that she has her own fortune. She argues that they have wronged her and that Duncan is obligated to stay with her, as she is his. Duncan, persuaded by her reasoning and his own desires, agrees to remain with her.

## Themes in this chapter

### Love and Sacrifice

Duncan's internal conflict between duty and his love for Lady Alice, and her argument that he must stay to save her from a life of darkness, highlight the theme of sacrifice for love.

### Isolation and Connection

Lady Alice describes her life as a 'dark moaning cavern' from which Duncan's love has called her forth, contrasting her previous isolation with the new connection she feels with him.

## Character check-ins

### Duncan Campbell

Experiences intense emotional turmoil and joy, struggling to maintain his sanity and duties. He questions whether he should leave, but is persuaded by Lady Alice's arguments.

### Lady Alice

Returns to Duncan after a week, revealing her true feelings and her belief that she is his. She argues that Lord Hilton and her stepmother have wronged her, and that Duncan is obligated to stay.

### Lord Hilton

Mentioned as Lady Alice's guardian and her stepmother's husband, who has wronged her by misrepresenting her and preventing her education.

### Lady Hilton

Mentioned as Lady Alice's stepmother, who, along with Lord Hilton, has wronged her.

## Key lines

> I dreaded a fever, lest I should talk in it, and drop the clue to my secret treasure.

He was afraid that a fever might make him delirious and reveal his secret love.

_Shows Duncan's fear of his secret being discovered._

> It would be to tell the soul which you have called forth, to go back into its dark moaning cavern, and never more come out to the light of day.

Leaving her would be like forcing the soul he awakened to return to its dark and lonely existence.

_Lady Alice's plea to Duncan, using powerful imagery to describe her former state._

> I can claim some compensation from them for the wrong they have been doing me.

She believes she is owed something to make up for the injustices she has suffered.

_Lady Alice's justification for her relationship with Duncan._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_portent_se/chapters/xiii-questioning
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_portent_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_portent_se/chapters