# Another Crime explained — The Old Wives’ Tale

> Chapter companion for The Old Wives’ Tale by Arnold Bennett.

## What happens

Samuel Povey becomes obsessed with saving his cousin Daniel Povey from execution after Daniel is condemned for murder. Despite his worsening health, Samuel tirelessly organizes a petition for reprieve, neglecting his business and straining his marriage with Constance. Constance, desperate to protect Samuel's health, fights with him but ultimately cannot stop his mission. The chapter details the town's shifting attitudes, the logistical challenges of the petition, and the emotional toll on Constance.

## Themes in this chapter

### Marriage and Domesticity

Constance and Samuel's marriage is strained by his obsessive mission, leading to a rare and bitter conflict that reveals the limits of her influence.

### Fate and the Irreversibility of Choices

Daniel Povey's condemnation and Samuel's relentless campaign highlight the irreversible consequences of past actions and the struggle against fate.

### Social Class and Respectability

Daniel's status as a Town Councillor and ex-chairman of the 'Felons' society underscores the shock of his fall from respectability, and the town's agitation reflects class-based notions of justice.

## Character check-ins

### Samuel Povey

Obsessed with saving Daniel Povey, he neglects his health and business, driving a wedge between himself and Constance.

### Constance Baines

Desperately tries to protect Samuel from his own zeal, resorting to hysterical arguments and elaborate preparations for his journey to Stafford.

### Daniel Povey

The condemned man, awaiting execution; Samuel works tirelessly for his reprieve.

### Cyril Povey

Accompanies his father Samuel to Knype station, acting as an escort under Constance's orders.

### Young Lawton

Visits Samuel to discuss the petition for Daniel's reprieve and helps organize the effort.

### Miss Insull

Her corner in the shop is occupied by Constance during the day.

### Mr. Brindley

Takes over Daniel Povey's business temporarily after Samuel consents to the arrangement.

## Key lines

> The structure of blind faith had once again crumbled at the assault of realities, and unhealthy, un-English truths, the statement of which would have meant ostracism twenty-four hours earlier, became suddenly the platitudes of the Square and the marketplace.

The townspeople's unwavering belief in Daniel's innocence collapsed under the weight of the guilty verdict, and opinions that would have been scandalous just a day before were now openly accepted.

_Illustrates the fickleness of public opinion and the power of reality to shatter illusions._

> She deliberately gave way to hysteria; she was no longer soft and gentle; she flung bitterness at him like vitriol; she shrieked like a common shrew.

Constance, in her desperation, abandoned her usual gentle demeanor and erupted in a furious, hysterical outburst against Samuel.

_Highlights the extreme emotional strain on Constance and the breakdown of her typical composure._

> He lived solely for Daniel's trial, pouring out money in preparation for it. He thought and spoke of nothing else. The affair was his one preoccupation.

Samuel devoted all his energy, resources, and thoughts to defending Daniel, to the exclusion of everything else in his life.

_Shows Samuel's obsessive dedication and the all-consuming nature of his mission._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_old_wives_tale_se/chapters/v-another-crime
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_old_wives_tale_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_old_wives_tale_se/chapters