# A Battle explained — The Old Wives’ Tale

> Chapter companion for The Old Wives’ Tale by Arnold Bennett.

## What happens

Mrs. Baines and Sophia clash over Sophia's future, with Sophia defiantly insisting on becoming a schoolteacher against her mother's wishes. After a tense struggle, Mrs. Baines reluctantly capitulates and arranges for Sophia to apprentice with Miss Chetwynd, marking a shift in the family's power dynamics.

## Themes in this chapter

### Female Identity and Independence

Sophia's fierce determination to become a teacher represents a rebellion against the domestic role expected of her, asserting her own identity and desire for autonomy.

### Motherhood and Family Dynamics

Mrs. Baines's internal suffering and eventual capitulation highlight the shifting power balance within the family, as she struggles between maternal authority and love for her daughter.

### Social Class and Respectability

Mrs. Baines's shock at Sophia's teaching plan reflects class-based assumptions about suitable occupations for a girl of her station, and the need to maintain respectability.

## Character check-ins

### Sophia Baines

Defiantly argues with her mother about leaving school and insists on becoming a teacher, eventually winning her mother's reluctant approval through sheer determination.

### Mrs. Baines

Struggles to maintain authority over Sophia, ultimately yielding to Sophia's plan after a painful internal conflict and a diplomatic interview with Miss Chetwynd.

### Constance Baines

Observes the conflict between Sophia and their mother, later learning of Sophia's success in enlisting Miss Chetwynd's help.

### Elizabeth Chetwynd

Visits Mrs. Baines at Sophia's behest, praising Sophia's individuality and helping to secure her apprenticeship.

### Reverend Archibald Jones

Mentioned as Miss Chetwynd's prospective brother-in-law and as a figure whose presence reassures Mrs. Baines about Sophia's future.

## Key lines

> I don't want to leave school at all, she said passionately. But you will have to leave school sooner or later, argued Mrs. Baines, with an air of quiet reasoning, of putting herself on a level with Sophia.

Sophia passionately declares she never wants to leave school, while Mrs. Baines calmly insists she must eventually.

_This exchange encapsulates the central conflict of the chapter: Sophia's desire for independence versus her mother's conventional expectations._

> I made Miss Chetwynd come and talk to mother, said Sophia magnificently one night to simple Constance, as if to imply, Your Miss Chetwynd is my washpot.

Sophia boasts to Constance that she orchestrated Miss Chetwynd's visit to persuade their mother, showing her strategic cunning.

_Reveals Sophia's manipulative skill and her triumph in the battle of wills with her mother._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_old_wives_tale_se/chapters/iii-a-battle
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_old_wives_tale_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_old_wives_tale_se/chapters