# XXIV: Poirot Gives Advice explained — The Mystery of the Blue Train

> Chapter companion for The Mystery of the Blue Train by Agatha Christie.

## What happens

Poirot reveals to Van Aldin that the Comte de la Roche intended only to steal the rubies, not murder Ruth, and that someone else—likely Derek Kettering—intervened. He explains his suspicions from the start, citing motive and opportunity. Later, Poirot observes Derek speaking with Katherine Grey outside the hotel and warns him about Mirelle. Derek admits his feelings for Katherine but is defiant. Poirot receives a call from Van Aldin confirming that the maid Mason now identifies Derek as the man in Paris.

## Themes in this chapter

### Deception and Appearances

Poirot reveals that the Comte de la Roche's plan was substitution, not murder, and that Derek may have impersonated the Comte, highlighting layers of deceit.

### Love and Marriage

Derek Kettering's open affection for Katherine Grey contrasts with his broken relationship with Mirelle and his wife's recent murder, exploring romantic entanglements.

### Justice and Morality

Poirot's investigation seeks the truth behind Ruth's murder, while Derek's moral character is questioned in light of his past and current feelings.

## Character check-ins

### Hercule Poirot

Explains his theory of the crime to Van Aldin, warns Derek about Mirelle, and receives confirmation from Van Aldin about Mason's identification.

### Rufus Van Aldin

Listens to Poirot's revelations about the Comte and Derek, and later calls Poirot to report Mason's certainty that the man in Paris was Derek.

### Derek Kettering

Seen speaking earnestly with Katherine Grey; later confronts Poirot about his feelings for Katherine and his break with Mirelle.

### Katherine Grey

Arrives in a car outside the hotel; Derek speaks with her earnestly before she drives off.

### Mirelle

Observed by Poirot waiting in a second car; Derek acknowledges she has not accepted their breakup.

### Ada Mason

Reported by Van Aldin to have come forward, now almost certain the man at Paris was Derek Kettering.

## Key lines

> It is well to be off with the old love, before being on with the new.

Poirot advises Derek to end his relationship with Mirelle before pursuing Katherine.

_Poirot quotes an English proverb to warn Derek about his romantic situation._

> Find Ruth's murderer for me, that is all I ask.

Van Aldin implores Poirot to discover who killed his daughter.

_Van Aldin's emotional plea to Poirot at the end of their conversation._

> The personality of a criminal, Georges, is an interesting matter. Many murderers are men of great personal charm.

Poirot remarks to his valet that criminals often have charismatic personalities.

_Poirot reflects on the nature of criminals after his meeting with Derek._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_mystery_of_the_blue_train_se/chapters/xxiv-poirot-gives-advice
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_mystery_of_the_blue_train_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_mystery_of_the_blue_train_se/chapters