# A Mystery to Be Solved explained — The Mysterious Island

> Chapter companion for The Mysterious Island by Jules Verne.

## What happens

The rescued castaway from Tabor Island struggles with his past, revealing he has been alone for twelve years. He resists integration into the colony, speaking only in anguished outbursts. Cyrus Smith and the others respect his silence while continuing their work, including building a windmill and harvesting a bountiful crop of corn. The chapter explores the mystery of the man's identity and his gradual, painful return to humanity.

## Themes in this chapter

### Redemption and Transformation

The Unknown's tears and gradual re-engagement with the colonists suggest a potential for redemption, as Cyrus Smith believes he can be 'made a man through his tears.'

### Isolation and Longing for Home

The Unknown's twelve years of solitude on Tabor Island and his anguished cries about being abandoned highlight the profound effects of isolation and the desire for connection.

### Community and Cooperation

The colonists work together to build a windmill and expand their farm, demonstrating their collective effort and mutual support.

## Character check-ins

### Cyrus Smith

Shows compassion and patience, insisting the colonists respect the Unknown's silence and wait for him to speak voluntarily.

### Gideon Spilett

Observes that the Unknown's first human sensation seems to be remorse, and speculates about the man's past.

### Pencroff

Suggests the man was left on Tabor Island as punishment for a crime, and notes the puzzling condition of the bottle and paper.

### Herbert Brown

Reports the Unknown's question about the month and year, revealing the man had lost track of time during his twelve years of isolation.

### Neb

Participates in the search when the Unknown flees, and works alongside the others on the plateau.

## Key lines

> Yes, the poor creature had wept. Some remembrance had flashed across his spirit, and, as Smith had said, he would be made a man through his tears.

The castaway cried, and Cyrus Smith believed that this emotional release would help him regain his humanity.

_Highlights the theme of redemption through emotional catharsis._

> Twelve years! Twelve years! he cried, and then turned quickly away.

He exclaimed that he had been alone for twelve years and then fled.

_Reveals the duration of his isolation and his distress._

> Why am I here? By what right did you drag me from my island? Is there any bond between you and me? Do you know who I am—what I have done—why I was there—alone?

He questioned why the colonists brought him back, insisting they did not understand his past or his crimes.

_Shows his inner turmoil and guilt about his history._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_mysterious_island_se/chapters/xxxviii
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_mysterious_island_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_mysterious_island_se/chapters