# Sergeant Smith Calls explained — The Man Who Knew > Chapter companion for The Man Who Knew by Edgar Wallace. ## What happens The chapter opens with the girl overhearing Jasper Cole accuse Frank Merrill of fraud, leading to a confrontation. Later, Sergeant Smith (Crawley) visits John Minute at Weald Lodge, threatening him with exposure of their shared criminal past in Matabeleland. The sergeant's visit is marked by tension and blackmail, revealing deep secrets between the two men. ## Themes in this chapter ### Secrecy and Knowledge The chapter revolves around hidden knowledge: Jasper Cole's accusation of fraud, the girl's eavesdropping, and Sergeant Smith's blackmail based on past crimes. ### Crime and Justice Themes of fraud, perjury, and blackmail are central, with Sergeant Smith threatening to expose John Minute's criminal past. ### Appearance vs. Reality John Minute appears as a respectable figure but is revealed to have a criminal history; Sergeant Smith presents as a law enforcer but is a blackmailer. ## Character check-ins ### The Girl Overhears Jasper Cole's accusation against Frank Merrill and confronts them, defending Frank. ### Jasper Cole Accuses Frank Merrill of fraud in a conversation with John Minute, later confronted by the girl. ### John Minute Receives Jasper Cole's report on the fraud and later is visited by Sergeant Smith, who threatens him with their shared past. ### Frank Merrill Accused of fraud by Jasper Cole; the girl defends him. ### Sergeant Smith Visits John Minute at Weald Lodge, threatening to expose their criminal history in Matabeleland. ### Constable Wiseman Reports John Minute's open windows to Sergeant Smith and discusses the sergeant's views on Minute. ## Key lines > The fraud has been worked by Frank. He had access to the books. He was the only person who saw Rex Holland; he was the only official at the bank who could possibly falsify the entries and at the same time hide his trail. Jasper Cole accuses Frank Merrill of committing fraud by manipulating the bank's books, given his unique access and role. _This accusation sets off the girl's defense of Frank and deepens the mystery._ > It is a lie! ... A horrible lie—and you know it is a lie, Jasper! The girl angrily denies Jasper's accusation against Frank, calling it a deliberate falsehood. _Shows the girl's loyalty to Frank and her distrust of Jasper._ > I have been into the books very carefully with Mackensen, the accountant, and there seems no doubt. Jasper Cole claims to have thoroughly examined the financial records with an accountant, confirming Frank's guilt. _Highlights Jasper's role as an investigator and the evidence against Frank._ > You are pretty cozy, John ... I thought I'd look you up. My constable reported your windows were open, and I felt it my duty to come along and warn you—there are thieves about, John. Sergeant Smith sarcastically greets John Minute, using the pretense of warning about thieves to initiate a threatening visit. _Reveals the sergeant's ulterior motive and his familiarity with Minute._ > I know of one ... Your constable, as you call him, is, I presume, that thickheaded jackass, Wiseman! John Minute retorts that he knows a thief (referring to Sergeant Smith) and dismisses Constable Wiseman as foolish. _Shows Minute's contempt for the police and his awareness of Smith's criminal past._ ## Links - HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_man_who_knew_se/chapters/viii-sergeant-smith-calls - Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_man_who_knew_se - All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_man_who_knew_se/chapters