# XVII: The Accusing Finger explained — The Eye of Osiris

> Chapter companion for The Eye of Osiris by R. Austin Freeman.

## What happens

Paul Berkeley reads a newspaper report that confirms the identity of John Bellingham's remains and the discovery of a ring, intensifying the suspicion surrounding the case. Thorndyke warns Paul that George Hurst may shift suspicion onto Ruth Bellingham, revealing a deliberate plot. Paul, distraught, visits Nevill's Court and realizes he is being watched by plainclothes policemen. Later, Thorndyke offers Paul a role in his investigation, and Paul reflects on his unrequited love for Ruth, writing her a letter of resignation before seeking companionship at King's Bench Walk.

## Themes in this chapter

### Grief and Suspense

Paul experiences intense grief over his lost hopes with Ruth and suspense over the impending danger to her reputation and safety.

### Deception and Truth

Thorndyke asserts that the appearances in the case are deceptive and part of a deliberate plot to mislead.

### Love and Romance

Paul's unrequited love for Ruth is central to his emotional state, culminating in a letter of devotion and resignation.

## Character check-ins

### Paul Berkeley

Paul is deeply distressed by the newspaper report and the threat to Ruth, and he later writes a letter renouncing his romantic hopes.

### John Thorndyke

Thorndyke reveals his belief in a deliberate plot against Ruth and offers Paul a role in his investigation.

### Jervis

Jervis is present during the discussion and is noted to be going on holiday soon.

### Ruth Bellingham

Ruth is the subject of Paul's love and the target of potential suspicion; Paul writes her a letter of devotion and resignation.

### George Hurst

Hurst is identified by Thorndyke as likely to shift suspicion onto Ruth to protect himself.

### Arthur Jellicoe

Jellicoe is seen passing Paul and his friends in the Lane, noted with surprise.

## Key lines

> Thus the identity of the body is established beyond all doubt, and the question that remains is, Who killed John Bellingham?

The remains are confirmed to be John Bellingham's, leaving only the question of his murderer.

_Newspaper report solidifying the case._

> But the circumstances convince me that there has been a deliberate plot; and I am waiting—in no spirit of Christian patience, I can tell you—to lay my hand on the wretch who has done this.

Thorndyke is certain that someone has orchestrated a scheme to frame Ruth, and he is eager to catch the culprit.

_Thorndyke's determination to uncover the truth._

> I will still be content, because your friendship, Ruth, is better than another woman’s love.

Paul tells Ruth that he values her friendship above any other romantic possibility.

_Paul's letter of resignation and devotion._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_eye_of_osiris_se/chapters/xvii-the-accusing-finger
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_eye_of_osiris_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_eye_of_osiris_se/chapters