# The Same to the Same explained — The Documents in the Case

> Chapter companion for The Documents in the Case by Dorothy L. Sayers.

## What happens

In this chapter, a letter dated 14th June, 1929, is presented. The writer, who signs as 'Lolo', responds to a hurtful letter from Petra. Lolo expresses deep distress over Petra's suggestion that Lolo should allow a divorce, which would bring public shame and scandal. Lolo argues that such a divorce would tarnish their pure love and that Petra's request proves Petra doesn't truly love her. Lolo suggests that if Petra insists, they should part forever, and hints at suicidal thoughts as an escape.

## Themes in this chapter

### Marriage and Gender Roles

The letter highlights the gendered impact of divorce, with Lolo fearing the permanent stain on her reputation as a woman, while noting that men are less affected.

### Repression and Psychoanalysis

Lolo's emotional turmoil and suggestion of suicide reflect repressed feelings and psychological distress, possibly hinting at deeper mental conflict.

## Character check-ins

### Lolo

The letter's author, expressing heartbreak and resistance to divorce, fearing public shame and loss of love.

### Petra

The recipient of the letter, who has suggested divorce as a solution, causing Lolo's distress.

## Key lines

> You can’t really think that if I love you I ought to let him divorce me.

You cannot genuinely believe that my love for you means I should agree to a divorce.

_Lolo challenges Petra's reasoning, equating love with a refusal to endure public humiliation._

> It would be better to suffer all our lives as we are suffering now—as I am suffering, for sometimes, Petra, I don’t think you suffer at all—rather than to look at each other with the shadow of an ugly scandal between us.

Enduring lifelong suffering is preferable to having a scandal taint our relationship, and I doubt you feel the same pain I do.

_Lolo prioritizes the purity of their love over personal happiness and questions Petra's emotional investment._

> I feel unhappy enough to die—and if I’m too strong for wretchedness to kill me, there are always easy ways out of it all.

I am so miserable that I could die, and if my suffering doesn't kill me, I can find other means to end my life.

_Lolo expresses suicidal ideation as a potential escape from the pain of separation._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_documents_in_the_case_se/chapters/40-the-same-to-the-same
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_documents_in_the_case_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/the_documents_in_the_case_se/chapters