# Brother and Sister explained — Simon

> Chapter companion for Simon by J. Storer Clouston.

## What happens

Ned Cromarty confronts his sister Lilian about who told him that Cicely Farmond was engaged to Malcolm Cromarty, a lie that fueled slander linking them to Sir Reginald's murder. Lilian admits she never actually said they were engaged, and Ned reveals the devastating consequences: the rumor led to Cicely being persecuted and nearly fleeing. He warns Lilian that Cicely is welcome at their home and that any further trouble will have consequences. Lilian deflects blame onto Simon Rattar, whom Ned told, and suggests Rattar spread the story to protect someone else. Ned decides to consult Mr. Carrington, and Lilian, suspecting Ned will marry Cicely, writes to arrange a long visit elsewhere.

## Themes in this chapter

### Family and Betrayal

Ned confronts his sister Lilian over her deception, which led to severe consequences for Cicely, highlighting betrayal within the family.

### Suspicion and Rumor

The false engagement rumor spreads slander about Malcolm and Cicely, driving Cicely to flee and prompting Ned to investigate the source.

### Secrecy and Silence

Lilian initially refuses to reveal who told her the rumor, and the chapter explores how secrets and silence enable harm.

## Character check-ins

### Ned Cromarty

Confronts his sister Lilian about the false engagement rumor, reveals its devastating consequences, and decides to consult Carrington.

### Lilian Cromarty

Initially evasive, she admits to misleading Ned about the engagement and deflects blame onto Simon Rattar; later writes to arrange a long visit away.

### Cicely Farmond

Discussed as the victim of the slander; Ned reveals she was driven to run away but he fetched her back and offered her refuge.

### Simon Rattar

Identified by Lilian as the likely spreader of the false rumor, accused of having a motive to shelter someone else.

### F. T. Carrington

Ned decides to consult him, describing him as an uncommon shrewd fellow.

### Malcolm Cromarty

Mentioned as the subject of the false engagement rumor that linked him to Cicely in a murder conspiracy.

## Key lines

> I never actually said they were engaged.

Lilian admits she never explicitly stated there was an engagement, only implied it.

_Lilian's evasion reveals the origin of the damaging rumor._

> I guess I’d better see Carrington.

Ned decides to consult the detective Carrington for help.

_Ned acknowledges he is out of his depth and turns to Carrington for professional investigation._

> He’s going to marry her!

Lilian concludes that Ned intends to marry Cicely.

_Lilian's suspicion motivates her to plan a long visit away from home._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/simon_se/chapters/xxix-brother-and-sister
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/simon_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/simon_se/chapters