# To a Certain Critic explained — Poetry

> Chapter companion for Poetry by George MacDonald.

## What happens

The speaker addresses a critic who was never the intended audience for his humble work. He had prepared simple, wholesome nourishment for humble souls, but the critic arrived, overturned the food, trampled it, and then disdainfully complained about the mess.

## Character check-ins

### Unknown

The speaker who prepared the homely dish for humble souls.

## Key lines

> Such guests as you, sir, were not in my mind When I my homely dish with care designed; ’Twas certain humble souls I would have fed Who do not turn from wholesome milk and bread: You came, slow-trotting on the narrow way, O’erturned the food, and trod it in the clay; Then low with discoid nostrils sniffing curt, Cried, “Sorry cook! why, what a mess of dirt!”

I never intended for critics like you to partake of my simple, carefully prepared work. I made it for humble people who appreciate plain, nourishing fare. You came along, knocked it over, trampled it, and then sniffed disdainfully, complaining about the dirt you yourself created.

_The speaker rebukes a critic for destroying his work and then blaming him for the resulting mess._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/poetry_8_se/chapters/to-a-certain-critic
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/poetry_8_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/poetry_8_se/chapters