# XIII: Catherine's Opinion explained — Hester

> Chapter companion for Hester by Margaret Oliphant.

## What happens

Catherine Vernon reflects on her own pettiness and the gossip surrounding Harry's courtship of Hester. She struggles with her magnanimous principles versus her jealous, controlling nature, especially as Edward grows distant. The chapter explores Catherine's role as a benevolent despot who must know everything, and her discomfort with Harry's independence and Hester's potential rise.

## Themes in this chapter

### Wealth and Morality

Catherine's wealth gives her power and a sense of duty, but also leads to pettiness and a warped view of others' motives. She gives liberally yet feels unappreciated, questioning the morality of her own judgments.

### Deception and Secrecy

Edward hides his resentment and desire for freedom from Catherine, while Catherine's surveillance of Harry's visits reveals a culture of secrecy and hidden motives within the family.

### Family and Obligation

Catherine feels obligated to manage her relatives' lives, but her sense of duty clashes with her personal biases. Edward feels bound by family duty, chafing against the yoke of Catherine's expectations.

## Character check-ins

### Catherine Vernon

Catherine is introspective, ashamed of her petty remarks about Mrs. John and Hester, yet unable to stop her critical thoughts. She feels a loss of control as Edward becomes distant and Harry pursues Hester.

### Edward Vernon

Edward resents his dependence on Catherine and feels trapped by his role as her representative. He is jealous of Harry's freedom to court Hester and becomes distant from Catherine, leaving her surprised.

### Harry Vernon

Harry is openly courting Hester, walking to the Vernonry in his summer clothes with honest intentions. He is confident she will accept him and plans to be good to her mother.

### Hester Vernon

Hester is the object of Harry's courtship and Catherine's scrutiny. Catherine assumes she is ambitious and will marry Harry for his wealth, though Hester's own feelings are not directly shown.

### John Vernon

Mrs. John is mentioned as Hester's mother, whose simplicity Catherine questions, suspecting she encourages Harry's visits to secure a good match for her daughter.

## Key lines

> It was wrong to speak as she had done about the astuteness of Mrs. John's simplicity. Why should not the mother wish to place her child in the position which she, after all by no fault of her own, poor creature! had lost?

Catherine feels guilty for mocking Mrs. John's supposed cleverness, recognizing that any mother would want her daughter to regain the social standing she lost through no fault of her own.

_Catherine's self-awareness and moral conflict are highlighted as she judges her own pettiness._

> It would have given Catherine Vernon a sharper shock still if she had seen into Edward's mind as he went away from her, bitterly feeling that while other men could taste the sweetness of freedom and of love, he was attached to an old woman's apron-strings.

Edward resents being tied to Catherine's whims, envying other men their freedom to love and act independently, a truth that would deeply shock Catherine if she knew.

_Edward's hidden bitterness contrasts with Catherine's belief in his contentment, foreshadowing future conflict._

> She liked her friends to bring her news, and never thought anything too trivial to be added to the mass of information which was in her hands.

Catherine encouraged gossip and collected every detail about her neighbors, believing no piece of information was too small to be useful.

_This describes Catherine's controlling nature and her role as a local 'visible Providence.'_

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/hester_se/chapters/xiii-catherine-s-opinion
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/hester_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/hester_se/chapters