# Mr. Gibson's Threat explained — He Knew He Was Right

> Chapter companion for He Knew He Was Right by Anthony Trollope.

## What happens

Miss Stanbury remains gravely ill, and the town of Exeter buzzes with rumors about her condition and will. Martha tries to steer her dying mistress toward piety, but Miss Stanbury struggles with worldly thoughts. Mr. Gibson calls, ostensibly to inquire after Miss Stanbury, but also to mend fences and hint at his upcoming marriage. Later, Mrs. French confronts Mr. Gibson about neglecting Camilla, and he threatens to leave for Natal rather than endure her accusations.

## Themes in this chapter

### Social Reputation and Gossip

Exeter buzzes with rumors about Miss Stanbury's will and health; Mr. Gibson's visits to the Close fuel gossip and accusations from the French family.

### Forgiveness and Reconciliation

Mr. Gibson seeks to make peace with Miss Stanbury and Dorothy, claiming to forgive and forget past harsh words, though his motives are mixed.

### Gender Roles and Power in Marriage

Mrs. French asserts her daughter's expectations of Mr. Gibson's evening attendance, while Mr. Gibson resists and threatens to escape the engagement entirely.

## Character check-ins

### Miss Jemima Stanbury

Lies gravely ill, too weak to resist Martha's pious ministrations, but inwardly questions deathbed piety and worldly sins.

### Dorothy Stanbury

Receives Mr. Gibson's visit with bewilderment; feels Martha's increased respect and is conflicted about allowing Gibson to see her aunt.

### Mr. Gibson

Visits to inquire after Miss Stanbury and to reconcile; later threatened by Mrs. French and responds by threatening to emigrate to Natal.

### Martha

Miss Stanbury's servant; urges piety on her mistress, mediates Mr. Gibson's visit to Dorothy, and shows increased respect toward Dorothy.

### Camilla French

Reported by her mother to be pining and jealous of Mr. Gibson's visits to the Close; threatens to make a row.

### Mrs. French

Confronts Mr. Gibson about neglecting Camilla, accusing him of spending too much time in the Close; briefly cowed by his threat to leave.

## Key lines

> I have learned to forgive and forget.

Mr. Gibson claims he has moved past the quarrel with Miss Stanbury.

_He uses this to justify his visit and seek reconciliation._

> I’ve been already invited to go to Natal, and if I hear anything more of these accusations, I shall certainly make up my mind to go.

Mr. Gibson threatens to emigrate to Natal if Mrs. French continues to accuse him.

_This is his ultimate threat to escape the marriage pressure._

> If cards were wicked, she had indeed been a terrible sinner. What hope could there be now, on her deathbed, for one so sinful?

Miss Stanbury reflects that if card-playing is sinful, her past life leaves her little hope of salvation.

_Shows her internal struggle with deathbed piety and worldly habits._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/he_knew_he_was_right_se/chapters/liv-mr-gibson-s-threat
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/he_knew_he_was_right_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/he_knew_he_was_right_se/chapters