# Letter XXXVIII: Mr. Villars to Lady Howard explained — Evelina

> Chapter companion for Evelina by Fanny Burney.

## What happens

Mr. Villars writes to Lady Howard recounting a visit from Madame Duval, who demands that Evelina be allowed to go to Paris or live with her in London. After a lengthy and unpleasant dispute, Mr. Villars reluctantly agrees to let Evelina spend one month with Madame Duval, fearing that refusing might cost Evelina her inheritance.

## Themes in this chapter

### Guardianship and Paternalism

Mr. Villars struggles with his authority as guardian against Madame Duval's legal and financial claims over Evelina.

### Family and Identity

Madame Duval asserts her role as grandmother, threatening to disinherit Evelina if her wishes are not obeyed.

### Virtue and Reputation

Mr. Villars fears the corrupting influence of Madame Duval's vulgarity and the company Evelina might keep in London.

## Character check-ins

### Rev. Mr. Villars

Writes to Lady Howard describing his difficult meeting with Madame Duval and his reluctant compromise.

### Madame Duval

Visits Berry Hill to demand authority over Evelina, threatening to disinherit her if opposed.

### Evelina Anville

The subject of the dispute; Mr. Villars agrees to let her spend a month with Madame Duval.

### Lady Howard

Recipient of the letter; Mr. Villars asks her to release Evelina when Madame Duval claims her.

### Sir John Belmont

Mentioned as the father whose return is awaited; Madame Duval wants Evelina to live in London until then.

## Key lines

> I never made a concession with so bad a grace, or so much regret.

Mr. Villars deeply regrets agreeing to let Evelina stay with Madame Duval.

_Expresses his reluctance and unhappiness with the compromise._

> The violence and vulgarity of this woman, her total ignorance of propriety, the family to which she is related, and the company she is likely to keep, are objections so forcible to her having the charge of this dear child...

Mr. Villars believes Madame Duval's coarse manners and associates make her an unfit guardian for Evelina.

_Highlights his concerns about Evelina's moral and social well-being._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/evelina_se/chapters/letter-xxxviii-mr-villars-to-lady-howard
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/evelina_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/evelina_se/chapters