# Law Business in London explained — Doctor Thorne

> Chapter companion for Doctor Thorne by Anthony Trollope.

## What happens

Frank Gresham travels to London to consult with Dr. Thorne and his family's lawyer, Mr. Bideawhile, about the financial implications of Sir Louis Scatcherd's death. He also shares Mary Thorne's letter with Dr. Thorne, seeking advice on whether to marry her despite his family's opposition. Dr. Thorne, aware that Mary is likely Sir Roger's heiress, hesitates to reveal this, while Frank insists on working for a living and marrying Mary soon.

## Themes in this chapter

### Inheritance and Wealth

The chapter revolves around Sir Roger Scatcherd's will and the potential inheritance for Mary Thorne, which could resolve the Gresham family's financial troubles and enable Frank and Mary's marriage.

### Love vs. Duty

Frank struggles between his love for Mary and his duty to his family, while Mary's letter suggests she may sacrifice her happiness for his sake, highlighting the tension between personal desire and familial obligation.

### Professional Dignity vs. Practicality

Frank considers taking up farming to support himself and Mary, a practical solution that contrasts with his family's expectations of maintaining their social status through wealth and marriage.

## Character check-ins

### Frank Gresham

Frank is in London to discuss legal matters and seeks Dr. Thorne's advice about Mary's letter, expressing his determination to marry her despite financial obstacles.

### Dr. Thorne

Dr. Thorne is in London after Sir Louis's funeral, consulting with lawyers. He is torn between revealing Mary's potential inheritance and keeping it secret, and he advises Frank to go home.

### Mary Thorne

Mary is referenced through her letter to Frank, which expresses her suffering and suggests they may need to part, though both Frank and Dr. Thorne believe she loves him.

### Mr. Bideawhile

Mr. Bideawhile is the family lawyer who engages Frank in a rambling conversation about wine, travel, and old times before Frank can discuss the mortgage.

### Louis Scatcherd

Sir Louis Scatcherd's recent death is a key topic, as it relieves Dr. Thorne and Frank's father from legal pressures and may affect the inheritance.

### Sir Roger Scatcherd

Sir Roger's will is discussed, with Dr. Thorne's law advisers opining that Mary Thorne is his undoubted heiress, though this is not yet confirmed to Frank.

## Key lines

> I will show it Dr. Thorne himself, said he, and ask him what he thinks.

Frank decides to show Mary's letter to Dr. Thorne and seek his opinion.

_Frank seeks Dr. Thorne's advice on how to respond to Mary's letter._

> It is impossible, he said, that matters should go on like that. Think what her sufferings must have been before she wrote that. I am sure she loves me.

Frank insists that the current situation is unbearable, believing Mary's letter reflects her deep suffering and love for him.

_Frank expresses his conviction that Mary loves him and that they cannot continue in uncertainty._

> Why not let me take a farm? My father could, at any rate, manage a couple of thousand pounds or so for me to stock it.

Frank proposes that he could become a farmer with a small loan from his father to support himself and Mary.

_Frank suggests a practical plan to earn a living through farming, despite his family's expectations._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/doctor_thorne_se/chapters/xlv-law-business-in-london
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/doctor_thorne_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/doctor_thorne_se/chapters