# The Secret of Macarger's Gulch explained — Can Such Things Be?

> Chapter companion for Can Such Things Be? by Ambrose Bierce.

## What happens

The narrator recounts a hunting trip in Macarger's Gulch where he camps in an abandoned cabin and experiences a strange, fearful night. Years later, he meets a man named Morgan who reveals that the cabin was the site of a murder: a woman named Janet MacGregor was found dead with a fractured skull, and her husband Thomas MacGregor was the prime suspect but never found. The narrator realizes his dream that night eerily matched the description of the couple, suggesting a supernatural connection.

## Themes in this chapter

### Death and the Supernatural

The discovery of a skeleton and the narrator's dream that mirrors the murder suggest a supernatural link between the living and the dead.

### Isolation and Terror

The narrator's fear in the isolated cabin, despite his usual comfort with solitude, highlights the terror of being alone in a place with a violent past.

### Guilt and Retribution

The unsolved murder of Janet MacGregor and the disappearance of her husband imply a crime without punishment, leaving a lingering sense of guilt.

## Character check-ins

### Hugh Morgan

The man who tells the narrator about the murder of Janet MacGregor in Macarger's Gulch.

### Janette Harford

Mrs. Morgan, who reacts with disgust to the gruesome details of the murder.

## Key lines

> I had a sense of comfort, but not of security.

The narrator felt physically comfortable but emotionally unsafe.

_Highlights the contrast between physical ease and psychological unease._

> The skull was fractured in several places, as by blows of some blunt instrument; and that instrument itself—a pick-handle, still stained with blood—lay under the boards near by.

The victim's skull had multiple fractures from a blunt object, and a blood-stained pick-handle was found nearby.

_Key evidence from the murder scene described by Morgan._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/can_such_things_be_se/chapters/the-secret-of-macarger-s-gulch
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/can_such_things_be_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/can_such_things_be_se/chapters