# XII: Antonio Spatola Appears explained — Ashton-Kirk, Investigator

> Chapter companion for Ashton-Kirk, Investigator by John T. McIntyre.

## What happens

Ashton-Kirk and Pendleton arrive at the City Hall cell room to find Osborne, Bernstine, and Sime already there. Sime identifies the bayonet but cannot identify Spatola as the buyer. Ashton-Kirk speaks with Spatola, learning of his past as a violinist and confirming his knowledge of German. When Ashton-Kirk subtly probes about musical shorthand, Spatola reacts with suspicion and anger, leading Pendleton to believe Spatola is the murderer.

## Themes in this chapter

### Detective Method and Reasoning

Ashton-Kirk uses subtle conversation to confirm Spatola's knowledge of German and shorthand, demonstrating his investigative technique.

### Secrecy and Deception

Spatola's angry denial of knowing shorthand suggests he is hiding something.

### Appearance vs. Reality

Spatola appears as a pitiful street musician but may be more cunning than he seems.

## Character check-ins

### Ashton Kirk

Interviews Spatola, subtly confirms his knowledge of German and shorthand.

### Pendleton

Observes Spatola's reactions and concludes he is the murderer.

### Antonio Spatola

Former first violinist, now a prisoner; denies buying the bayonet and reacts angrily to questions about shorthand.

### Osborne

Brings Bernstine and Sime to identify the bayonet; conducts the initial interrogation.

### Mr. Bernstine

Arrives with Sime to assist in identifying the bayonet; expresses disappointment at not being informed earlier.

### Sime

Identifies the bayonet but cannot identify Spatola as the buyer.

## Key lines

> I came here to have a few words with this prisoner, and by your leave, I'll speak to him now.

Ashton-Kirk asks Osborne for permission to interview Spatola alone.

_Ashton-Kirk takes control of the interrogation._

> I have read it in the German; in his own language, just as he wrote it. It is nothing.

Spatola admits he can read German, confirming a key point for Ashton-Kirk.

_Ashton-Kirk cleverly elicits confirmation of Spatola's German literacy._

> I know nothing of such things, and what is more I don't want to know anything of them.

Spatola angrily denies any knowledge of shorthand when Ashton-Kirk brings up musical shorthand.

_Spatola's defensive reaction suggests he is hiding something._

## Links

- HTML: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/ashton_kirk_investigator_se/chapters/xii-antonio-spatola-appears
- Book: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/ashton_kirk_investigator_se
- All chapters: https://www.betterreads.online/discover/ashton_kirk_investigator_se/chapters